AlphaMaven AlphaMaven

Court freezes former UJ official’s pension over alleged accommodation fraud

Reported by Insideeducation
Nov 16, 2026· 4 min read
Save Post LinkedIn Email
Key Takeaways
  • • The Johannesburg High Court ordered the University of Johannesburg Pension Fund to withhold pension benefits of former senior administrator Mzwakhe Matukane pending finalisation of a civil claim the university brought against him in the Labour Court.
  • • Judge Nelisa Mali, in a judgment handed down on 5 November, found UJ had established a prima facie case of dishonesty, while stressing no final finding of fraud had been made.
  • • The university alleges about R400,096 was paid to a private accommodation provider in July and August 2023 for students who denied living there, and that Matukane's transactions of approximately R821,112.28 could not be reconciled with his declared income.
  • • The pension freeze was granted because the amount UJ seeks to recover is substantially higher than Matukane's pension benefits, and he was ordered to pay costs on an attorney-and-client scale.
  • • The ruling follows a separate Labour Court judgment ordering former senior director of student affairs Andries Helani to repay more than R18 million after he accepted over R3.2 million in bribes from private student accommodation providers.
Summary
The University of Johannesburg (UJ) has secured a Johannesburg High Court order preventing former senior administrator Mzwakhe Matukane from accessing his pension benefits while the university pursues a civil claim against him in the Labour Court. The claim concerns alleged involvement in a fraudulent student accommodation payment scheme. The court directed the University of Johannesburg Pension Fund to withhold the benefits until those civil proceedings are finalised, according to the source report by Thapelo Molefe.

The application followed a 15 September decision by the pension fund board to release Matukane's benefits, which the fund confirmed in correspondence to his legal representatives dated 23 September, subject to the submission of required documents. The fund had questioned whether UJ had established sufficient legal grounds under section 37D of the Pension Funds Act. It acknowledged that some allegations could support a damages claim for negligence or gross negligence, but said they did not necessarily establish theft, fraud or dishonest misconduct.

In a judgment handed down on 5 November, Judge Nelisa Mali found that UJ had established a prima facie case of dishonesty. The case rests on allegations that Matukane authorised payments to a private accommodation provider even though students denied living at the premises. The judge cited in particular an August 2023 incident in which Matukane was allegedly told that two students had expressly denied being accommodated, yet allegedly instructed that outstanding payments proceed. The university alleges that about R400,096 was paid to the provider in two instalments in July and August 2023, with a substantial portion later transferred to a representative linked to another accommodation provider. A lifestyle audit identified bank accounts linked to Matukane, his spouse and associated entities, and transactions of approximately R821,112.28 that investigators said could not readily be reconciled with his declared income.

Matukane disputes the allegations, maintaining that payments followed established procedures and that UJ has not shown he acted dishonestly. He says he blew the whistle on the disputed transaction and that a payment of about R97,000 from Old Mutual in his bank account is unrelated to the scheme. Judge Mali said the allegations must be considered collectively and stressed that no definitive finding of fraud had been made, leaving his explanations open for the Labour Court hearing. The court found UJ had shown a sufficient basis to preserve the benefits, particularly because the sum sought is substantially higher than the pension. Matukane was ordered to pay the High Court application costs on an attorney-and-client scale.

The ruling follows a separate Labour Court judgment against former senior director of student affairs Andries Helani, who was ordered to repay more than R18 million after being found to have accepted bribes from private student accommodation providers. Helani received more than R3.2 million through 366 payments between March 2021 and March 2024 while overseeing accreditation of privately owned student residences funded through the National Student Financial Aid Scheme (NSFAS). Judge Reynaud Daniels found he had failed to declare his relationships with providers and helped secure accreditation for two Braamfontein properties approved for 1,441 students that had only 299 beds. Inspectors found only one UJ student in each building, and the applicant, Mahlatse Investments, did not own or manage the properties. The university paid just over R17 million to entities linked to the properties, and its payment merchant, Fundi Capital, claimed more than R1 million in fees.

Go deeper than the headline

Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.

Start your free 7-day trial

Sources

1 outlet

AlphaMaven summarised this story from the reporting below. Each link opens the original article.

Insideeducation Court freezes former UJ official’s pension over alleged accommodation fraud