Key Takeaways
- • The highest-return NPS pension fund is not automatically the most suitable choice, because a fund's past one- or three-year returns may not match an investor's age, retirement timeline, or risk tolerance.
- • Returns must be compared only among schemes in the same asset class, since equity, corporate bond, and government securities schemes behave differently under market stress.
- • Under Active Choice, subscribers can allocate up to 75% to equity under common NPS schemes, while Auto Choice reduces equity exposure automatically as the subscriber ages, with conservative, moderate, and aggressive lifecycle options offered by PFRDA.
- • Under the All Citizen Model, subscribers can change their pension fund manager once per financial year and change their investment choice or asset allocation up to four times per financial year.
- • Investors should evaluate five- and ten-year returns against the relevant benchmark and watch for sequence-of-returns risk as retirement approaches.
Summary
The article stresses that comparisons should be made between schemes investing in the same asset class. NPS investments are divided among equity, corporate bonds and government securities. Equity offers higher long-term return potential but greater volatility, corporate bonds provide a relatively stable profile subject to credit and interest rate risk, and government securities carry low credit risk while their market values can move with interest rates. Comparing an equity scheme with a government securities scheme, the article says, does not fairly indicate which pension fund manager is stronger. It also recommends examining multi-year returns and measuring performance against the relevant benchmark, noting that a fund returning 10% has underperformed if its benchmark returned 12%.
On allocation, subscribers choose between Active Choice, where they set the split among equity, corporate bonds and government securities with equity up to 75% under common schemes, and Auto Choice, where allocation shifts automatically toward lower equity exposure as the subscriber ages. PFRDA offers conservative, moderate and aggressive lifecycle options under Auto Choice. The article notes that the allocation decision may matter more than the choice of manager, and that a 30-year-old and a 55-year-old retiring at 60 face different needs. It highlights sequence-of-returns risk: a sharp equity decline shortly before retirement can reduce a corpus, such as one of Rs 1 crore, at the point when withdrawals and annuity purchases are planned, leaving less time to recover than a younger investor would have.
On switching, the article notes that under the All Citizen Model subscribers may change pension fund manager once in a financial year and alter their investment choice or asset allocation up to four times in a financial year. It cautions that frequent switching based on short-term performance can disrupt a long-term strategy. A change of manager is more appropriate after sustained deterioration in performance, repeated benchmark underperformance, or concerns about investment approach, and temporary underperformance may reflect broader asset class conditions rather than manager quality. The article concludes that there is no automatic answer and that suitability depends on age, risk tolerance, other retirement assets, and income stability.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.