Key Takeaways
- • The UK government has not set a timeline for releasing £1.2bn from the Mineworkers Pension Scheme Guarantor's Fund to former miners, despite expectations that it would be paid out at the November Budget.
- • Chancellor John Healey and Gary Saunders, chair of the MPS Trustees, agreed in a meeting last week to work together to resolve the matter "within the coming weeks," per a joint statement issued close to midnight.
- • Coalfield Labour MPs have threatened to rebel against the Finance Bill and to force a Commons debate if the issue is not resolved, according to openDemocracy.
- • The National Union of Mineworkers estimates miners have lost out on more than £4.4bn since British Coal's 1994 privatisation, when the Treasury gained access to pension surplus reserves in exchange for guaranteeing benefits.
- • The Treasury has not explained the last-minute reversal, and the prime minister has said the money must be scored on the public balance sheet, while minister Blair McDougall said no accounting rule changes are required.
Summary
A meeting between Healey and Gary Saunders, chair of the Mineworkers Pension Scheme (MPS) trustees, took place last week without concrete steps. The chancellor agreed to work with the trustees and their advisers to resolve the issue "within the coming weeks," according to the joint statement, which was not released until almost midnight. Campaigners say the agreement reached earlier in the day was withdrawn without explanation.
The background traces to the 1994 privatisation of British Coal, when the Treasury agreed to guarantee workers' pensions in exchange for 50% of any investment surplus. The funds never fell into deficit, so the Treasury never paid in but still gained access to the reserves. The National Union of Mineworkers estimates miners have lost more than £4.4bn as a result. Former chancellor Rachel Reeves released one MPS fund in 2024 and the British Coal Staff Superannuation Scheme fund last year; the Guarantor's Fund is the last remaining pot.
Coalfield Labour MPs, including Kate Osbone (Jarrow and Gateshead East) and Jon Trickett (Normanton and Hemsworth), are pressing for release and have threatened to rebel against the Finance Bill and to force a debate if the matter is unresolved. Osbone noted the government has already returned £1.5bn to members. The MPS told openDemocracy that dozens of scheme members have died since the Budget.
On the funding question, openDemocracy reported MPs believe the cash was held up by a Treasury "blunder" the night before the Budget speech. Prime Minister Keir Starmer's comments that the money "does have to be scored on the public balance sheet" were disputed by reindustrialisation minister Blair McDougall, who confirmed the release would not require changes to accounting rules. The government maintains it will release the funds eventually, but many miners remain skeptical given past promises.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.