Key Takeaways
- • Alternative assets represent an "important and growing fundamental trend" in pension investment, with structural changes in both defined benefit (DB) and defined contribution (DC) markets set to release new sources of capital for long-term allocation over the short to medium term, according to Pensions Policy Institute (PPI) research sponsored by the World Gold Council.
- • Open DB schemes and Local Government Pension Scheme (LGPS) funds have already established alternatives as a core allocation component, with further growth expected; conversely, closed DB schemes face a transition period as improved solvency positions prompt trustees targeting buyouts to divest alternative assets ahead of insurer transactions.
- • Alternative investments have demonstrated capacity to generate improved member outcomes and long-term secure income streams, with the broader pension universe increasingly viewing alternatives as a hedge for diversification and alpha generation relative to traditional public markets.
- • Historical data shows allocations to alternatives among pension "risky" investments rose from 14% in 2001 to 39% by 2021, driven by institutional conviction that alternatives deliver superior risk-adjusted returns compared to conventional equity and fixed-income exposures.
Summary
Pension funds are shifting meaningfully toward alternative assets as a strategic allocation, reflecting both structural market changes and institutional confidence in alternatives' ability to enhance risk-adjusted returns and member outcomes. Research from the Pensions Policy Institute, sponsored by the World Gold Council, confirms that changes across the defined benefit and defined contribution pension landscapes will unlock new capital flows destined for long-term investment vehicles, with alternatives positioned to capture a growing share of these allocations alongside traditional public markets.
The adoption pattern differs materially between open and closed DB schemes. Open DB schemes and LGPS funds have already incorporated alternatives into standard asset allocations, with expectations for further expansion. These schemes view alternatives—spanning private equity, real estate, private credit, and other diversified holdings—as vehicles for generating stable, long-term income streams aligned with member retirement objectives. However, closed DB schemes are experiencing a period of transition accelerated by recent solvency improvements. The PPI noted that trustees in closed schemes targeting buyout transactions with specialist insurers face pressure to divest remaining alternative positions as part of pre-transaction portfolio optimization, temporarily offsetting growth trends elsewhere in the market.
The institutional shift toward alternatives reflects a decades-long reallocation of risk capital. Between 2001 and 2021, alternative assets grew from 14% to 39% of pension funds' "risky" allocations, demonstrating sustained conviction among asset owners that alternatives deliver superior alpha and diversification benefits relative to traditional public equities and bonds. The PPI's research confirms this trend remains topical, with material evidence of continued asset allocation changes unfolding across the pension industry. While most released capital will continue flowing to traditional public markets, the research suggests alternatives are well-positioned for scaled growth that can meaningfully improve pension member outcomes in an environment where trustees increasingly demand both enhanced returns and liability-driven income generation.
The adoption pattern differs materially between open and closed DB schemes. Open DB schemes and LGPS funds have already incorporated alternatives into standard asset allocations, with expectations for further expansion. These schemes view alternatives—spanning private equity, real estate, private credit, and other diversified holdings—as vehicles for generating stable, long-term income streams aligned with member retirement objectives. However, closed DB schemes are experiencing a period of transition accelerated by recent solvency improvements. The PPI noted that trustees in closed schemes targeting buyout transactions with specialist insurers face pressure to divest remaining alternative positions as part of pre-transaction portfolio optimization, temporarily offsetting growth trends elsewhere in the market.
The institutional shift toward alternatives reflects a decades-long reallocation of risk capital. Between 2001 and 2021, alternative assets grew from 14% to 39% of pension funds' "risky" allocations, demonstrating sustained conviction among asset owners that alternatives deliver superior alpha and diversification benefits relative to traditional public equities and bonds. The PPI's research confirms this trend remains topical, with material evidence of continued asset allocation changes unfolding across the pension industry. While most released capital will continue flowing to traditional public markets, the research suggests alternatives are well-positioned for scaled growth that can meaningfully improve pension member outcomes in an environment where trustees increasingly demand both enhanced returns and liability-driven income generation.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.