Key Takeaways
- • Oaktree Capital Management's April 2012 IPO underperformed expectations, placing 8.8 million shares at $43 (the bottom of its price range) rather than the originally targeted 11 million shares, raising $380 million and listing on the NYSE under ticker "OAK."
- • Oaktree shares declined below their IPO price on the first day of trading, signaling weak investor demand for the $75 billion distressed debt manager's public debut.
- • Alternative asset managers that previously went public have delivered poor stock performance: Blackstone is down roughly 50% since its 2007 IPO, while Fortress and Och-Ziff have performed even worse; Apollo Global Management is off approximately 20%, with only KKR showing significant gains at 30%-plus.
- • The weak Oaktree reception raises broader questions about whether retail and institutional investors can profitably access alternative asset management strategies once exclusive to elite institutional and ultra-high-net-worth investors.
- • Carlyle Group is positioned to follow Oaktree with its own IPO roadshow the following week, entering a market skeptical of alternative asset manager public listings.
Summary
Oaktree Capital Management's initial public offering on April 12, 2012, underperformed market expectations in a development that signals broader investor skepticism toward alternative asset manager IPOs. The firm, the industry's largest distressed debt manager with $75 billion in assets under management, priced 8.8 million shares at $43—the bottom end of its projected range and below its original target of 11 million shares. The offering raised $380 million and listed on the New York Stock Exchange under ticker "OAK," but shares declined from the IPO price during the company's first day of trading, indicating weak investor appetite.
The lackluster reception reflects a challenging track record for alternative asset managers that have already gone public. Blackstone Group shares have declined approximately 50% since its 2007 IPO, while Fortress Investment Group and Och-Ziff Capital Management have fared even worse. More recent listings tell a mixed story: Apollo Global Management shares are off roughly 20% from their IPO levels, while KKR & Co. stands as a rare exception among alternative asset managers, posting gains exceeding 30%. This performance history has evidently made institutional and retail investors cautious about accessing alternative strategies through public equity markets.
The timing of Oaktree's weak IPO adds irony to the broader narrative. On the same day Oaktree priced its offering, Aleris International—a once-bankrupt steel manufacturer and one of Oaktree's restructuring portfolio investments—scrapped its own planned IPO, underscoring the challenging market conditions for capital raises in early 2012.
Looking ahead, Carlyle Group is positioned to launch its own IPO roadshow the following week, entering a market increasingly skeptical of whether average stock market investors can profitably access Wall Street's "exclusive private-equity and debt trading clubs," according to the original reporting. The question facing institutional investors and asset allocators is whether the public equity discount at which these firms are trading represents genuine structural concerns about alternative asset management businesses or a temporary market dislocations.
The lackluster reception reflects a challenging track record for alternative asset managers that have already gone public. Blackstone Group shares have declined approximately 50% since its 2007 IPO, while Fortress Investment Group and Och-Ziff Capital Management have fared even worse. More recent listings tell a mixed story: Apollo Global Management shares are off roughly 20% from their IPO levels, while KKR & Co. stands as a rare exception among alternative asset managers, posting gains exceeding 30%. This performance history has evidently made institutional and retail investors cautious about accessing alternative strategies through public equity markets.
The timing of Oaktree's weak IPO adds irony to the broader narrative. On the same day Oaktree priced its offering, Aleris International—a once-bankrupt steel manufacturer and one of Oaktree's restructuring portfolio investments—scrapped its own planned IPO, underscoring the challenging market conditions for capital raises in early 2012.
Looking ahead, Carlyle Group is positioned to launch its own IPO roadshow the following week, entering a market increasingly skeptical of whether average stock market investors can profitably access Wall Street's "exclusive private-equity and debt trading clubs," according to the original reporting. The question facing institutional investors and asset allocators is whether the public equity discount at which these firms are trading represents genuine structural concerns about alternative asset management businesses or a temporary market dislocations.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.