AlphaMaven AlphaMaven

Pension settlement could raise investment consultants’ accountability, plaintiffs’ lawyers say

Reported by Pensions & Investments
Nov 17, 2026· 3 min read
Save Post LinkedIn Email
Key Takeaways
  • • A $34.5 million settlement resolves Steinke, et al v. Aon Investments USA, Inc. et al, a suit over advice given to the $90.9 billion Pennsylvania Public School Employees' Retirement System (PennPSERS), Harrisburg.
  • • Defendants named in the case are Aon Investments USA, Aksia, Hamilton Lane Advisors and Portfolio Advisors, now combined with FS Investments as Future Standard; the PennPSERS board was not sued due to governmental immunity.
  • • Plaintiffs' attorneys J.J. Conway and Gerard Mantese say the settlement is precedent-setting because it shifts scrutiny from the pension plan to the consultants and advisers that shape its investment decisions.
  • • The case challenges PennPSERS' shift into alternatives, which Conway's Nov. 5 release said reached 56% in 2016 versus a 26% national average, while returns lagged similar-sized public pensions.
  • • Defendants Aon and Aksia settled without admitting wrongdoing or liability; Hamilton Lane and Portfolio Advisors deny the allegations, and Future Standard declined comment.
Summary
A $34.5 million settlement in a lawsuit against four investment consultants and advisers could strengthen accountability for firms that influence investment decisions for large pension plans, according to plaintiffs' lawyers J.J. Conway, principal attorney of J.J. Conway Law, and Gerard Mantese, CEO of Mantese Honigman. The case, Steinke, et al v. Aon Investments USA, Inc. et al, named Aon Investments USA, Aksia, Hamilton Lane Advisors and Portfolio Advisors, which is now combined with FS Investments into Future Standard. Conway and Mantese served as co-counsel for approximately 170,000 PennPSERS members, according to a Nov. 5 news release from J.J. Conway Law. Conway said it was the first time participants were able to get past immunity issues and sue the advisers directly; the PennPSERS board was not sued due to governmental immunity.

The plaintiffs allege the defendants breached fiduciary duties to participants by advising the pension to move from traditional publicly traded investments into alternatives, which the release described as risky and non-transparent, including private equity, hedge funds, private credit and venture capital. The release stated that PSERS had the highest alternatives allocation in the nation in 2016 at 56%, against a national average of 26%, while its investment returns were consistently among the lowest among public pensions of similar size. Pensions & Investments' annual top 1,000 survey put PennPSERS' alternatives allocation at 44.6% as of Sept. 30, 2016, including private equity, real estate and other alternatives. The case evaluates investment decisions from 2011 onward, when PennPSERS moved from a defined benefit plan to a combined defined contribution and DB model with shared risk, under which participant contributions can change depending on plan funding. Because the plan missed its ten-year performance threshold, participants faced higher contributions from July 1, 2021 through June 30, 2024, according to the lawsuit.

A PennPSERS spokesperson said the plan is not a party to the litigation or settlement and could not provide details beyond the public notice on its website. A Future Standard spokesperson declined to comment. Aon, Aksia and Hamilton Lane did not immediately respond to requests for comment; the settlement states that Aon and Aksia made no admission of wrongdoing or liability, while Hamilton Lane and Portfolio Advisors deny the allegations.

Mantese said some recommendations involve investments where he doubts the adviser would invest personally, yet they advise pension funds to commit hundreds of millions of dollars. Conway said consultants may give more weight to their constituencies and align recommendations with values. Mantese expects advisers to be more careful and to conduct better due diligence. Conway also hopes the case broadens rights for public pension participants, who lack the protections of ERISA, which does not cover public plans, calling it "one small step" toward reducing their second-class status.

Go deeper than the headline

Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.

Start your free 7-day trial

Sources

1 outlet

AlphaMaven summarised this story from the reporting below. Each link opens the original article.

Pensions & Investments Pension settlement could raise investment consultants’ accountability, plaintiffs’ lawyers say