Key Takeaways
- • JPMorgan analysts led by Nikolaos Panigirtzoglou argue Bitcoin could receive stronger price support than gold if hedging demand in ETF markets eases, based on positioning asymmetries between the two assets.
- • BlackRock's iShares Bitcoin Trust (IBIT) short interest reached 45.9 million shares as of August 31, 2026—the highest level of the year and up 23.8% from 37.1 million shares two weeks earlier—representing 3.53% of the fund's float.
- • IBIT's put-to-call open interest ratio exceeds that of the SPDR Gold Shares ETF (GLD), signaling heavier hedging activity around Bitcoin, while GLD short interest remains below its historical average.
- • Both Bitcoin and gold ETFs received inflows following the Federal Reserve's late-July meeting when the debasement trade re-emerged; Bitcoin rallied toward $80,000 and gold approached $4,600 per ounce on US fiscal concerns and investor rotation into scarce assets.
- • Momentum in both assets faded over the prior week as inflation-adjusted bond yields rose and the Senate failed to advance the CLARITY Act in a procedural vote that fell short of the 60-vote threshold required for passage.
Summary
JPMorgan's research team contends that Bitcoin faces a more defensive positioning backdrop than gold, creating potential for relative outperformance if current hedging pressures unwind. The analysis centers on structural differences in how institutional investors are currently positioned across Bitcoin and gold ETF products, suggesting that elevated short interest and put hedging in Bitcoin vehicles could flip into tailwinds once those protective positions are reduced.
The data supporting this thesis is substantial. IBIT's short base of 45.9 million shares as of August 31 represents the year's peak and reflects a dramatic 23.8% increase from the 37.1 million shares recorded just two weeks prior. This short position equals 3.53% of the fund's float and would require approximately 0.6 days of IBIT's average daily trading volume—roughly 53 million shares—to fully cover. For context, the short position stood at only 13 million shares at the end of March 2026. The more elevated put-to-call open interest ratio for IBIT compared to GLD further underscores that market participants are currently more defensive on Bitcoin than on gold.
Both assets benefited from inflows following the Federal Reserve's late-July meeting, when expectations around currency debasement and fiscal stimulus re-entered investor consciousness. This period drove Bitcoin toward $80,000 and gold near $4,600 per ounce, as institutional capital rotated into assets perceived as hedges against US fiscal imbalances. However, the rally proved short-lived. Recent weeks saw momentum fade as inflation-adjusted bond yields climbed and legislative efforts stalled—specifically, the Senate's procedural vote on the CLARITY Act fell short of the 60 votes required for advancement, removing a potential crypto-friendly policy catalyst.
JPMorgan's positioning analysis suggests that if hedging demand moderates and short positions are unwound, Bitcoin could benefit from greater structural support than gold. The bank acknowledges other factors will influence both assets' trajectories, but from a pure positioning perspective, the asymmetry between IBIT's elevated defensive measures and GLD's below-average short interest creates an imbalance that may eventually resolve in Bitcoin's favor as institutional investors reduce hedges.
The data supporting this thesis is substantial. IBIT's short base of 45.9 million shares as of August 31 represents the year's peak and reflects a dramatic 23.8% increase from the 37.1 million shares recorded just two weeks prior. This short position equals 3.53% of the fund's float and would require approximately 0.6 days of IBIT's average daily trading volume—roughly 53 million shares—to fully cover. For context, the short position stood at only 13 million shares at the end of March 2026. The more elevated put-to-call open interest ratio for IBIT compared to GLD further underscores that market participants are currently more defensive on Bitcoin than on gold.
Both assets benefited from inflows following the Federal Reserve's late-July meeting, when expectations around currency debasement and fiscal stimulus re-entered investor consciousness. This period drove Bitcoin toward $80,000 and gold near $4,600 per ounce, as institutional capital rotated into assets perceived as hedges against US fiscal imbalances. However, the rally proved short-lived. Recent weeks saw momentum fade as inflation-adjusted bond yields climbed and legislative efforts stalled—specifically, the Senate's procedural vote on the CLARITY Act fell short of the 60 votes required for advancement, removing a potential crypto-friendly policy catalyst.
JPMorgan's positioning analysis suggests that if hedging demand moderates and short positions are unwound, Bitcoin could benefit from greater structural support than gold. The bank acknowledges other factors will influence both assets' trajectories, but from a pure positioning perspective, the asymmetry between IBIT's elevated defensive measures and GLD's below-average short interest creates an imbalance that may eventually resolve in Bitcoin's favor as institutional investors reduce hedges.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.