Key Takeaways
- • SEC approved in-kind creation and redemption mechanisms for bitcoin and ether ETPs on July 29, 2025, departing from the cash-only model used in initial spot crypto ETF approvals and aligning with standard commodity-based ETP practices.
- • In-kind redemptions reduce operational costs and increase efficiency for authorized participants and investors by enabling direct asset exchange rather than requiring cash settlements, creating a more liquid and dynamic market structure.
- • SEC Chairman Paul S. Atkins signaled a regulatory pivot toward "fit-for-purpose" crypto framework development, indicating accelerated approval pathways for staking ETFs, altcoin baskets, DeFi index funds, and other structured crypto products currently in the SEC's queue.
- • The approval establishes foundational infrastructure for next-generation crypto ETPs that require Investment Company Act of 1940 framework clarification, including staking yield mechanisms and diversified digital asset exposure.
- • New guidance from the SEC and IRS on staking taxation and protocol activities is expediting the approval timeline for crypto ETF products, positioning the U.S. regulatory environment to compete internationally in institutional crypto asset management.
Summary
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission voted on July 29, 2025, to approve in-kind creation and redemption mechanisms for bitcoin and ether exchange-traded products, marking a significant departure from the cash-only settlement structure applied to the first wave of spot crypto ETF approvals. The decision, announced by the SEC, permits authorized participants to exchange actual cryptocurrency holdings directly for ETP shares, rather than requiring dollar-based transactions. This operational change mirrors the standard practices already embedded in commodity-based exchange-traded products and represents a deliberate effort to enhance market efficiency and reduce transaction costs.
SEC Chairman Paul S. Atkins framed the approval as central to his stated priority of developing a "fit-for-purpose regulatory framework for crypto asset markets." The timing and scope of the decision signal a meaningful shift in the Commission's approach, moving away from the restrictive controls applied in 2024 toward a more flexible, market-functional model. According to the SEC's Division of Trading and Markets Director Jamie Selway, the in-kind mechanism provides "flexibility and cost savings to ETP issuers, authorized participants, and investors, resulting in a more efficient market." These structural improvements lower barriers to entry and operational drag, key factors institutional investors evaluate when selecting crypto exposure vehicles.
Beyond the immediate bitcoin and ether impact, the SEC's framework revision establishes regulatory scaffolding for a broader pipeline of crypto-linked ETPs awaiting approval. Staking ETFs, altcoin basket funds, decentralized finance index products, and other structured crypto vehicles currently queued in the SEC system require clarification under the Investment Company Act of 1940 before launch. The Commission's concurrent guidance on protocol staking activities and IRS coordination on digital asset taxation is accelerating the timeline for these next-generation products. Multiple sources indicate that clearer rules on staking mechanics—specifically what qualifies as "protocol staking activities"—are now enabling sponsors to advance submissions with greater regulatory clarity.
The strategic implications extend to market structure and institutional adoption. In-kind mechanisms reduce slippage and creation/redemption spreads, making crypto ETPs more competitive with direct spot market purchases and traditional mutual fund alternatives. For hedge funds, family offices, and institutional allocators, lower operational friction translates to tighter bid-ask spreads and more predictable execution. The SEC's willingness to align crypto ETP standards with commodity ETPs signals confidence in the asset class maturation and regulatory finality, potentially unlocking large-scale institutional capital deployment in U.S.-domiciled crypto vehicles.
SEC Chairman Paul S. Atkins framed the approval as central to his stated priority of developing a "fit-for-purpose regulatory framework for crypto asset markets." The timing and scope of the decision signal a meaningful shift in the Commission's approach, moving away from the restrictive controls applied in 2024 toward a more flexible, market-functional model. According to the SEC's Division of Trading and Markets Director Jamie Selway, the in-kind mechanism provides "flexibility and cost savings to ETP issuers, authorized participants, and investors, resulting in a more efficient market." These structural improvements lower barriers to entry and operational drag, key factors institutional investors evaluate when selecting crypto exposure vehicles.
Beyond the immediate bitcoin and ether impact, the SEC's framework revision establishes regulatory scaffolding for a broader pipeline of crypto-linked ETPs awaiting approval. Staking ETFs, altcoin basket funds, decentralized finance index products, and other structured crypto vehicles currently queued in the SEC system require clarification under the Investment Company Act of 1940 before launch. The Commission's concurrent guidance on protocol staking activities and IRS coordination on digital asset taxation is accelerating the timeline for these next-generation products. Multiple sources indicate that clearer rules on staking mechanics—specifically what qualifies as "protocol staking activities"—are now enabling sponsors to advance submissions with greater regulatory clarity.
The strategic implications extend to market structure and institutional adoption. In-kind mechanisms reduce slippage and creation/redemption spreads, making crypto ETPs more competitive with direct spot market purchases and traditional mutual fund alternatives. For hedge funds, family offices, and institutional allocators, lower operational friction translates to tighter bid-ask spreads and more predictable execution. The SEC's willingness to align crypto ETP standards with commodity ETPs signals confidence in the asset class maturation and regulatory finality, potentially unlocking large-scale institutional capital deployment in U.S.-domiciled crypto vehicles.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.