Key Takeaways
- • Market-neutral and long-short equity funds, including prominent hedge funds, have underperformed significantly in 2018 year-to-date, despite being designed to deliver positive returns across market conditions.
- • The JP Morgan Hedged Equity fund (Bronze-rated by Morningstar) employs an option-overlay strategy to reduce equity volatility while maintaining long equity exposure, generating a 7% annualized three-year return with 6% standard deviation—outperforming the S&P 500 on a risk-adjusted basis.
- • Options-based hedging strategies can provide downside protection during market declines of 5% to 20% per quarter while capping upside participation, targeting a risk/return profile similar to a 60/40 portfolio at approximately half S&P 500 volatility.
- • Alternative fund strategies—particularly market-neutral approaches—continue to face headwinds despite Morningstar's confidence in their long-term value proposition for institutional investors seeking absolute returns and capital preservation.
Summary
Equity long-short and market-neutral hedge funds have experienced a painful 2018 performance stretch, falling short of their fundamental objective to generate positive returns regardless of market direction. According to Morningstar analysis, several prominent hedge funds and alternative mutual funds categorized as Medalist funds have struggled in the current year, raising questions about the efficacy of strategies designed to provide downside protection and market-neutral exposure.
The underperformance has been particularly acute for market-neutral long-short strategies, which typically construct portfolios by taking equal-value long positions in undervalued equities and short positions in overvalued equities to isolate alpha generation while neutralizing systematic market risk. Analysts observe that these funds are expected to continue underperforming other hedge fund strategies, with event-driven and CTA (Commodity Trading Advisor) approaches showing greater resilience in the current market environment.
In response to market volatility, alternative fund managers have increasingly adopted options-based hedging overlays to manage equity risk without fully abandoning upside exposure. The JP Morgan Hedged Equity fund, co-managed by Hamilton Reiner and Raffaele Zingone, exemplifies this approach. The strategy combines a 100% long equity portfolio (closely replicating the S&P 500 Index) with a disciplined quarterly option overlay designed to provide downside protection during periods when the S&P 500 declines between 5% and 20% per quarter. Over a three-year period, this fund generated a 7% annualized return with 6% standard deviation—delivering superior risk-adjusted returns compared to the S&P 500 index and ranking among the top three funds in its Option Writing category by absolute performance.
This outcome-oriented approach targets a risk/return profile similar to a traditional 60/40 portfolio while delivering roughly half the volatility of the S&P 500 Index, positioning it as an attractive option for institutional investors seeking equity exposure with enhanced downside mitigation and reduced duration risk. Morningstar maintains confidence in the long-term prospects of these alternative strategies despite near-term headwinds, viewing the option-writing approach as a viable framework for investors prioritizing risk-adjusted returns over absolute equity performance.
The underperformance has been particularly acute for market-neutral long-short strategies, which typically construct portfolios by taking equal-value long positions in undervalued equities and short positions in overvalued equities to isolate alpha generation while neutralizing systematic market risk. Analysts observe that these funds are expected to continue underperforming other hedge fund strategies, with event-driven and CTA (Commodity Trading Advisor) approaches showing greater resilience in the current market environment.
In response to market volatility, alternative fund managers have increasingly adopted options-based hedging overlays to manage equity risk without fully abandoning upside exposure. The JP Morgan Hedged Equity fund, co-managed by Hamilton Reiner and Raffaele Zingone, exemplifies this approach. The strategy combines a 100% long equity portfolio (closely replicating the S&P 500 Index) with a disciplined quarterly option overlay designed to provide downside protection during periods when the S&P 500 declines between 5% and 20% per quarter. Over a three-year period, this fund generated a 7% annualized return with 6% standard deviation—delivering superior risk-adjusted returns compared to the S&P 500 index and ranking among the top three funds in its Option Writing category by absolute performance.
This outcome-oriented approach targets a risk/return profile similar to a traditional 60/40 portfolio while delivering roughly half the volatility of the S&P 500 Index, positioning it as an attractive option for institutional investors seeking equity exposure with enhanced downside mitigation and reduced duration risk. Morningstar maintains confidence in the long-term prospects of these alternative strategies despite near-term headwinds, viewing the option-writing approach as a viable framework for investors prioritizing risk-adjusted returns over absolute equity performance.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.