Key Takeaways
- • eBay agreed to pay nearly $50 million in a settlement with Massachusetts couple David and Ina Steiner, founders of EcommerceBytes newsletter, resolving a lawsuit over harassment by former employees spanning more than six years of criminal and civil proceedings.
- • The settlement includes an additional $7 million in charitable donations directed toward organizations supporting First Amendment rights, underscoring the case's implications for press freedom and corporate accountability.
- • The agreement contains no confidentiality clause, allowing the Steiners to publicly discuss the campaign of intimidation, which included death threats, cyberstalking, in-person surveillance, and bizarre anonymous deliveries such as live insects, funeral wreaths, and a bloody pig mask.
- • The case originated from a 2021 lawsuit alleging eBay engaged in a conspiracy to "intimidate, threaten to kill, torture, terrorize, stalk and silence" the couple in order to suppress their e-commerce industry reporting.
- • The settlement signals significant reputational and financial consequences for corporations attempting to suppress critical press coverage, with legal counsel emphasizing that the resolution serves as a warning against attempts by large businesses to silence independent journalism.
Summary
eBay has reached a settlement worth nearly $50 million with David and Ina Steiner, a Massachusetts couple and founders of EcommerceBytes, a newsletter covering the e-commerce industry. The agreement, announced Tuesday following multiple legal proceedings spanning over six years, resolves allegations that former eBay employees engaged in an extensive harassment campaign against the couple to suppress their reporting on the company.
The Steiners initially filed suit in Boston federal court in 2021, alleging that eBay had orchestrated a conspiracy to "intimidate, threaten to kill, torture, terrorize, stalk and silence them" with the explicit purpose of silencing their e-commerce industry coverage. The harassment campaign included death threats, cyberstalking, in-person surveillance, and anonymous deliveries of disturbing items including live cockroaches, funeral wreaths, and a bloody pig Halloween mask. The couple faced a coordinated effort involving multiple former employees targeting them over an extended period.
The settlement, which took months to finalize after a tentative agreement was reached in February, includes $50 million in direct payments plus an additional $7 million in charitable donations to organizations supporting First Amendment rights. Notably, the agreement contains no confidentiality provision, a provision the Steiners insisted upon to ensure their ability to speak publicly about the harassment and its circumstances. Christopher Murphy, the couple's attorney from Massachusetts-based Scalli Murphy Law, framed the resolution as a significant statement on corporate accountability, saying it serves "a warning that attempts by big business to suppress speech and the press will not be tolerated."
The case underscores heightened legal and reputational risks for corporations that attempt to suppress independent journalism or critical coverage. Murphy characterized the harassment as "not only an attack and campaign of harassment against two people; it was also an attack on free speech and freedom of the press," highlighting the broader implications beyond the individual plaintiffs. The settlement's lack of confidentiality and substantial damage award signal substantial consequences for corporate efforts to intimidate media critics.
The Steiners initially filed suit in Boston federal court in 2021, alleging that eBay had orchestrated a conspiracy to "intimidate, threaten to kill, torture, terrorize, stalk and silence them" with the explicit purpose of silencing their e-commerce industry coverage. The harassment campaign included death threats, cyberstalking, in-person surveillance, and anonymous deliveries of disturbing items including live cockroaches, funeral wreaths, and a bloody pig Halloween mask. The couple faced a coordinated effort involving multiple former employees targeting them over an extended period.
The settlement, which took months to finalize after a tentative agreement was reached in February, includes $50 million in direct payments plus an additional $7 million in charitable donations to organizations supporting First Amendment rights. Notably, the agreement contains no confidentiality provision, a provision the Steiners insisted upon to ensure their ability to speak publicly about the harassment and its circumstances. Christopher Murphy, the couple's attorney from Massachusetts-based Scalli Murphy Law, framed the resolution as a significant statement on corporate accountability, saying it serves "a warning that attempts by big business to suppress speech and the press will not be tolerated."
The case underscores heightened legal and reputational risks for corporations that attempt to suppress independent journalism or critical coverage. Murphy characterized the harassment as "not only an attack and campaign of harassment against two people; it was also an attack on free speech and freedom of the press," highlighting the broader implications beyond the individual plaintiffs. The settlement's lack of confidentiality and substantial damage award signal substantial consequences for corporate efforts to intimidate media critics.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.