Key Takeaways
- • Eric Mindich announced the closure of Eton Park Capital Management on March 23, 2017, marking the first major hedge fund shutdown of 2017 and signaling deepening industry-wide challenges in the $3 trillion hedge fund sector.
- • Eton Park's flagship fund posted a 9.4% loss in 2016 with assets declining from $9 billion to approximately $7 billion, prompting Mindich's decision to return capital to investors rather than compromise the fund's investment program.
- • The fund will return approximately 40% of outside investor capital by the end of April 2017, with the Manhattan-based firm expected to complete full wind-down operations following its 13-year existence since 2004 launch.
- • Mindich, 49, a former Goldman Sachs partner who became the youngest partner in the firm's history at age 25 while heading the arbitrage desk, cited "industry headwinds, a difficult market environment and our own disappointing 2016 results" as reasons for closure.
- • The closure reflects broader industry turmoil: 2016 witnessed hundreds of hedge fund closures due to poor performance, investor redemptions, and persistent complaints regarding elevated fee structures, with similar high-profile closings including Richard Perry's Perry Capital.
Summary
Eric Mindich announced on March 23, 2017, that he would shut down Eton Park Capital Management, the hedge fund he founded in 2004. The decision represents a significant moment for the hedge fund industry, as Eton Park becomes the first major fund closure of 2017 and arrives amid ongoing structural challenges affecting the $3 trillion hedge fund sector. Mindich, a 49-year-old former Goldman Sachs executive who became the youngest partner in the bank's history at age 25, notified employees and sent a letter to investors detailing the decision to wind down the fund.
Eton Park's financial deterioration was substantial. The fund's flagship vehicle posted a 9.4% loss in 2016, with assets shrinking from $9 billion to approximately $7 billion. Performance remained flat in early 2017, compounding the losses from the prior year. In his investor letter, Mindich attributed the closure decision to "a combination of industry headwinds, a difficult market environment, and, importantly, our own disappointing 2016 results." He emphasized that the firm was unwilling to compromise on its business model or investment program to retain assets, opting instead to return capital to investors.
The wind-down will occur in phases, with approximately 40% of outside investor capital returned by the end of April 2017. Mindich's decision was also influenced by concern that declining assets would make it increasingly difficult to retain employees—a critical issue for investment management firms facing capital outflows.
The closure reflects systemic challenges across the hedge fund industry. 2016 marked one of the worst years for hedge fund closures since the financial crisis, with hundreds of smaller funds shutting down due to poor performance, investor redemptions, and escalating complaints regarding fee structures. Notable closures included Richard Perry's Perry Capital, which ceased operations after years of underperformance. Industry observers point to choppy markets and extended periods of placid global conditions as contributing factors to the broader malaise affecting hedge fund performance and asset retention.
Eton Park's financial deterioration was substantial. The fund's flagship vehicle posted a 9.4% loss in 2016, with assets shrinking from $9 billion to approximately $7 billion. Performance remained flat in early 2017, compounding the losses from the prior year. In his investor letter, Mindich attributed the closure decision to "a combination of industry headwinds, a difficult market environment, and, importantly, our own disappointing 2016 results." He emphasized that the firm was unwilling to compromise on its business model or investment program to retain assets, opting instead to return capital to investors.
The wind-down will occur in phases, with approximately 40% of outside investor capital returned by the end of April 2017. Mindich's decision was also influenced by concern that declining assets would make it increasingly difficult to retain employees—a critical issue for investment management firms facing capital outflows.
The closure reflects systemic challenges across the hedge fund industry. 2016 marked one of the worst years for hedge fund closures since the financial crisis, with hundreds of smaller funds shutting down due to poor performance, investor redemptions, and escalating complaints regarding fee structures. Notable closures included Richard Perry's Perry Capital, which ceased operations after years of underperformance. Industry observers point to choppy markets and extended periods of placid global conditions as contributing factors to the broader malaise affecting hedge fund performance and asset retention.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.