Key Takeaways
- • Mets owner Steve Cohen characterized the firing of manager Carlos Mendoza on Friday as a "mercy shot," citing the decision not to extend Mendoza's contract as the primary driver behind the termination.
- • The Mets fell to 34-47 under Mendoza's management in his third season after being swept at home by the Cubs, representing a sharp reversal from his inaugural 89-73 campaign that reached the NLCS in 2024.
- • Cohen disclosed that President of Baseball Operations David Stearns will remain in his role despite roster overhauls that "mostly backfired," with the organization posting a 119-129 record since the start of the 2025 season.
- • Andy Green assumed interim manager duties following Mendoza's departure, as Cohen acknowledged that managerial tenures are not permanent and roster management challenges have compounded organizational performance.
- • The decision reflects organizational dysfunction stemming from failed front-office roster construction rather than on-field management failure, with Cohen citing defensive lapses (six errors in a single game) as symptomatic of broader talent and depth deficiencies.
Summary
Steve Cohen, owner of the New York Mets, disclosed the rationale behind the franchise's firing of manager Carlos Mendoza in an exclusive interview on the New York Post Sports podcast. Cohen framed the termination as a "mercy shot," emphasizing that the central question guiding the decision was whether the organization would extend Mendoza's contract. When the answer proved negative, Cohen stated he and David Stearns, the team's President of Baseball Operations, agreed that relieving Mendoza of his duties at that juncture was the humane course of action.
The timing of the dismissal coincided with a four-game home sweep by the Chicago Cubs, leaving the Mets with a 34-47 record through Mendoza's third season at the helm. This marks a dramatic deterioration from Mendoza's debut season in 2024, when the team compiled an 89-73 regular-season record and advanced to the National League Championship Series. The franchise missed the playoffs entirely in 2025 at 83-79, and the cumulative record under Mendoza since the start of the 2025 campaign stands at 119-129, underscoring sustained underperformance.
Cohen attributed the poor on-field results to organizational deficiencies rather than managerial incompetence, citing specific instances of defensive breakdowns—including a game where the Mets committed six errors followed by two errors the next day. This framing aligns with Cohen's acknowledgment that Stearns' roster overhauls have "mostly backfired," suggesting that front-office personnel decisions bear primary responsibility for the team's struggles. Notably, Cohen reaffirmed that Stearns will retain his position as President of Baseball Operations.
Andy Green was named interim manager to replace Mendoza. Cohen concluded his comments by normalizing managerial transitions in professional sports, stating that few managers remain in their positions indefinitely and that organizational change is a routine aspect of the industry. The decision reflects broader tensions within the franchise between strategic roster construction and on-field execution, with the owner signaling that lame-duck status becomes untenable regardless of managerial competence.
The timing of the dismissal coincided with a four-game home sweep by the Chicago Cubs, leaving the Mets with a 34-47 record through Mendoza's third season at the helm. This marks a dramatic deterioration from Mendoza's debut season in 2024, when the team compiled an 89-73 regular-season record and advanced to the National League Championship Series. The franchise missed the playoffs entirely in 2025 at 83-79, and the cumulative record under Mendoza since the start of the 2025 campaign stands at 119-129, underscoring sustained underperformance.
Cohen attributed the poor on-field results to organizational deficiencies rather than managerial incompetence, citing specific instances of defensive breakdowns—including a game where the Mets committed six errors followed by two errors the next day. This framing aligns with Cohen's acknowledgment that Stearns' roster overhauls have "mostly backfired," suggesting that front-office personnel decisions bear primary responsibility for the team's struggles. Notably, Cohen reaffirmed that Stearns will retain his position as President of Baseball Operations.
Andy Green was named interim manager to replace Mendoza. Cohen concluded his comments by normalizing managerial transitions in professional sports, stating that few managers remain in their positions indefinitely and that organizational change is a routine aspect of the industry. The decision reflects broader tensions within the franchise between strategic roster construction and on-field execution, with the owner signaling that lame-duck status becomes untenable regardless of managerial competence.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.