Key Takeaways
- • The Managed Funds Association (MFA) filed a formal complaint against the London Metal Exchange over its March 8 suspension of nickel trading and cancellation of thousands of trades during a severe price surge and short squeeze.
- • The LME's decision to halt and cancel nickel trades—only the second such cancellation in the exchange's 145-year history—triggered allegations that the bourse failed to meet its regulatory obligations to maintain orderly markets, manage conflicts of interest, and protect investors.
- • MFA Chief Counsel Jennifer Han stated the LME "undermined confidence in its ability to oversee markets" by not performing its regulatory duties during the volatile nickel trading period that generated billions of dollars in margin calls.
- • The complaint follows litigation filed days earlier by two affiliates of Elliott Management and Jane Street Global trading against the LME over the same March nickel market disruption.
- • The escalating legal and regulatory pressure reflects institutional investor concerns about market integrity and the LME's crisis response during extreme commodity volatility.
Summary
The Managed Funds Association, a prominent trade body representing major hedge funds and alternative investment managers, filed a formal complaint with the London Metal Exchange on June 9, 2022, challenging the exchange's handling of nickel market turmoil that occurred in early March. The complaint centers on the LME's decision to suspend nickel trading and cancel thousands of transactions executed during the early hours of March 8, 2022, when nickel prices surged dramatically amid a short squeeze that threatened market stability and triggered billions of dollars in margin calls.
According to the MFA's complaint, the LME failed to fulfill its core regulatory obligations, specifically its duty to maintain an orderly market, manage conflicts of interest, and protect investors participating in the nickel market. Jennifer Han, the MFA's chief counsel, emphasized that the LME's actions "undermined confidence in its ability to oversee markets by failing to perform its regulatory obligations." The trade cancellation marked only the second instance in the London Metal Exchange's 145-year history that it had cancelled trading in one of its metals, underscoring the exceptional nature of the March disruption.
The formal complaint adds significant institutional pressure on the LME, which is owned by Hong Kong Exchanges and Clearing (HKEX), at a moment when the exchange already faces active litigation. Days before the MFA's filing, two affiliates associated with hedge fund Elliott Management and quantitative trading firm Jane Street Global filed lawsuits against the LME regarding the same March nickel market suspension and trade cancellations. The convergence of these complaints and lawsuits from sophisticated market participants signals deep concerns among institutional investors about the LME's regulatory framework and its crisis management protocols during periods of extreme commodity volatility.
According to the MFA's complaint, the LME failed to fulfill its core regulatory obligations, specifically its duty to maintain an orderly market, manage conflicts of interest, and protect investors participating in the nickel market. Jennifer Han, the MFA's chief counsel, emphasized that the LME's actions "undermined confidence in its ability to oversee markets by failing to perform its regulatory obligations." The trade cancellation marked only the second instance in the London Metal Exchange's 145-year history that it had cancelled trading in one of its metals, underscoring the exceptional nature of the March disruption.
The formal complaint adds significant institutional pressure on the LME, which is owned by Hong Kong Exchanges and Clearing (HKEX), at a moment when the exchange already faces active litigation. Days before the MFA's filing, two affiliates associated with hedge fund Elliott Management and quantitative trading firm Jane Street Global filed lawsuits against the LME regarding the same March nickel market suspension and trade cancellations. The convergence of these complaints and lawsuits from sophisticated market participants signals deep concerns among institutional investors about the LME's regulatory framework and its crisis management protocols during periods of extreme commodity volatility.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.