AlphaMaven AlphaMaven

Hedge fund pressures Invitation Homes to speed up home sales

Reported by Housingwire
Nov 16, 2026· 4 min read
Save Post LinkedIn Email
Key Takeaways
  • • Activist Land & Buildings Investment Management, the Stamford, Connecticut hedge fund led by Jonathan Litt, is pressing Invitation Homes (NYSE: INVH) to accelerate home sales, return at least $2 billion a year to shareholders and curtail acquisitions and development.
  • • Land & Buildings estimates a net asset value of about $45 per share, more than 65% above the current trading price after assuming 6% selling costs, and says the market values Invitation Homes' homes at roughly $270,000 each versus an average sale price near $460,000.
  • • The firm says Invitation Homes has lagged the S&P 500, the REIT index, American Homes 4 Rent and its compensation peer group over one-, three- and five-year periods, and that five-year shareholders have lost more than 20% including dividends.
  • • The letter criticizes more than $79 million in legal settlements, including a $48 million FTC settlement in 2024, and more than $25 million in special retention awards approved in March 2026 for the CEO and three other executives.
  • • Land & Buildings objected to the November 11 appointment of Cousins Properties CEO Colin Connolly to the board and signaled it will take further steps, pointing toward a possible proxy fight ahead of the 2027 proxy season.
Summary
Activist investor Land & Buildings Investment Management is pressing Invitation Homes, the nation's largest owner of single-family rental homes with more than 80,000 properties, to speed up home sales, sharply increase capital returns and scale back growth plans. In an open letter to shareholders released Monday, the Stamford, Connecticut-based hedge fund described the company as "among the most undervalued companies in the REIT sector" and criticized the board and management for "complacency" and "half measures." Land & Buildings, which holds an undisclosed stake, is led by Jonathan Litt.

The central argument is a valuation gap. According to the letter, public markets value Invitation Homes' properties at roughly $270,000 per home, compared with an average sale price of about $460,000 on homes sold since December 2025, an implied discount of about 40%. Land & Buildings said it independently valued more than 90% of the wholly owned portfolio address by address at an average of about $425,000 per home, producing a net asset value estimate of about $45 per share, more than 65% above the current price after assuming 6% selling costs. The letter, disseminated via GlobeNewswire, cites an implied capitalization rate of about 7%, roughly 60 basis points wider than American Homes 4 Rent.

The firm also highlighted sustained underperformance. Over the trailing one-, three- and five-year periods, Invitation Homes has lagged the S&P 500, the broader REIT index, American Homes 4 Rent and the board's compensation proxy peer group. Over three years it ranks second to last in that group, trailing the group average by more than 35 percentage points. Land & Buildings said five-year shareholders have lost more than 20% including dividends, even as national home prices have risen nearly 80% since the company's $20 IPO in early 2017. It blamed capital allocation, noting the company was a net buyer of homes in every year from 2022 through 2025, and said earnings have "repeatedly fallen short of expectations."

The letter also raised governance and legal costs. Invitation Homes has paid more than $79 million to resolve four legal matters related to resident treatment and business practices, including a $48 million settlement with the Federal Trade Commission in 2024. The board approved more than $25 million in special retention awards in March 2026 for the CEO and three other executives. Land & Buildings objected to the board's November 11 appointment of Colin Connolly, CEO of office REIT Cousins Properties, as a director, arguing that the board had previously said refreshment was unnecessary and that another sitting REIT chief executive offered "duplicative skill sets."

Land & Buildings proposed a three-part plan: commit to at least $2 billion a year in capital returns on a leverage-neutral basis, funded by selling homes individually; offer existing tenants a 6% rebate toward a down payment if they buy the home they rent, which the firm says roughly matches open-market sale costs; and significantly curtail external growth, as there is "no better use of the Company's capital than its own stock." The firm estimated nearly $40 billion of gross asset value supports a multi-year program that could deliver "substantial annual accretion" to earnings and NAV per share. It cited Green Street's view from less than a year ago that Invitation Homes should shrink its portfolio and return capital. Invitation Homes did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Land & Buildings said it will work "constructively" with the company but "will not hesitate to take whatever steps we believe are necessary to maximize value."

Go deeper than the headline

Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.

Start your free 7-day trial

Sources

1 outlet

AlphaMaven summarised this story from the reporting below. Each link opens the original article.

Housingwire Hedge fund pressures Invitation Homes to speed up home sales