Key Takeaways
- • Steve Cohen declined to re-sign Pete Alonso to a long-term contract, offering a 7-year deal that the five-time All-Star ultimately rejected, leading to Alonso's departure as a free agent and subsequent signing with the Baltimore Orioles.
- • Alonso's return to Citi Field as an opposing player triggered significant fan backlash against the Mets front office, with "We Want Pete" chants and stadium demonstrations reflecting dissatisfaction with organizational decision-making around the franchise's marquee player.
- • Cohen stated he did not have final conversations with Alonso before the player's departure, and Alonso confirmed no exit dialogue occurred, indicating a breakdown in direct ownership-player communication during the contractual negotiation process.
- • The decision to let Alonso depart remains a contentious organizational issue among the fan base, with criticism directed at Cohen's front office for failing to retain a generational player and fan favorite during a critical roster evaluation period.
Summary
Mets owner Steve Cohen addressed the controversial departure of Pete Alonso following the five-time All-Star's return to Citi Field as a member of the Baltimore Orioles on September 20, 2026. The situation represents a significant organizational failure in player retention, as Cohen's front office permitted one of baseball's most marketable talents to leave as a free agent rather than securing a long-term contract.
According to available reporting, Cohen offered Alonso a 7-year contract, which the player declined. Rather than continuing negotiations or presenting alternative proposals, the organization allowed Alonso to enter the free agent market, where he ultimately signed with Baltimore. Cohen indicated that the front office's responsibility centered on evaluating future outcomes and contractual value, suggesting the organization determined Alonso's asking price exceeded the team's assessment of his long-term performance projection.
The Alonso exit has created a visible rift between ownership and the fan base. During Alonso's return appearance at Citi Field, spontaneous "We Want Pete" chants erupted from the crowd, demonstrating sustained fan frustration with the decision. Multiple sources indicate that the cheering was not necessarily rooted in support for the opposing team, but rather reflected frustration with what fans characterized as front office arrogance in allowing the heart of the lineup to depart.
Notably, both Cohen and Alonso confirmed that no final conversations transpired between the owner and player before Alonso's free agency announcement. Alonso stated he was surprised by the news of his non-retention, indicating a breakdown in direct communication at the highest levels of the organization. This absence of dialogue between ownership and a generational franchise player underscores potential governance issues within the Mets' decision-making structure during a critical roster evaluation period.
According to available reporting, Cohen offered Alonso a 7-year contract, which the player declined. Rather than continuing negotiations or presenting alternative proposals, the organization allowed Alonso to enter the free agent market, where he ultimately signed with Baltimore. Cohen indicated that the front office's responsibility centered on evaluating future outcomes and contractual value, suggesting the organization determined Alonso's asking price exceeded the team's assessment of his long-term performance projection.
The Alonso exit has created a visible rift between ownership and the fan base. During Alonso's return appearance at Citi Field, spontaneous "We Want Pete" chants erupted from the crowd, demonstrating sustained fan frustration with the decision. Multiple sources indicate that the cheering was not necessarily rooted in support for the opposing team, but rather reflected frustration with what fans characterized as front office arrogance in allowing the heart of the lineup to depart.
Notably, both Cohen and Alonso confirmed that no final conversations transpired between the owner and player before Alonso's free agency announcement. Alonso stated he was surprised by the news of his non-retention, indicating a breakdown in direct communication at the highest levels of the organization. This absence of dialogue between ownership and a generational franchise player underscores potential governance issues within the Mets' decision-making structure during a critical roster evaluation period.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.