Key Takeaways
- • Mets' 2026 season performance is historically poor: The team holds a 35-49 record, sits 15 games behind first place in the NL East, and is 9.5 games out of the final wild-card spot despite maintaining one of MLB's top payrolls—reflecting a significant return-on-investment failure for owner Steve Cohen's aggressive spending strategy.
- • Manager Carlos Mendoza fired amid organizational crisis: Cohen made the high-profile decision to terminate the manager following the team's fourth consecutive series loss, including a 5-4 defeat to the Philadelphia Phillies, intensifying scrutiny of front office leadership under President of Baseball Operations David Stearns.
- • Cohen engaged in public social media response to both criticism and antisemitic harassment: The Mets owner personally responded on X (formerly Twitter) to a fan's antisemitic insult directed at his faith, stating "Thanks for reminding me why I shouldn't tweet," while also defending the removal of a fan displaying a "Fire Stearns" sign from a recent game.
- • Organizational dysfunction and fan discontent at critical juncture: Since acquiring the Mets in 2020, Cohen's tenure has produced inconsistent results, with the franchise making the playoffs only twice despite significant capital investment, and mounting pressure from fans and media regarding baseball operations strategy.
- • Cohen committed to addressing stakeholders: The owner signaled plans to speak directly to media soon regarding the team's on-field struggles and organizational decisions, indicating an attempt to restore confidence amid season-long collapse.
Summary
The New York Mets' 2026 season has devolved into organizational crisis, with owner Steve Cohen facing mounting criticism as the franchise struggles despite substantial payroll investment. As of late June, the team's record stands at 35-49, placing them 15 games out of first place in the National League East and 9.5 games from playoff contention. This performance deficit is particularly acute given that the Mets maintain one of baseball's highest payrolls—a structural disconnect that underscores the return-on-investment challenges plaguing Cohen's ownership since his 2020 acquisition.
The organization's operational difficulties intensified when Cohen made the decision to terminate manager Carlos Mendoza following a fourth consecutive series loss, including a Saturday defeat to the Philadelphia Phillies. This move, orchestrated alongside President of Baseball Operations David Stearns, represents a significant tactical shift mid-season but has failed to arrest the cascade of negative sentiment surrounding the franchise. The Mets' historical record under Cohen's ownership further complicates the narrative: since 2020, the organization has made the playoffs on only two occasions despite aggressive offseason spending directed by Stearns and Cohen jointly.
Cohen himself became the focus of organizational turbulence when he engaged directly on social media to address both legitimate team criticism and a targeted antisemitic insult. Responding on X to an expletive-laden post attacking his faith, Cohen wrote: "Thanks for reminding me why I shouldn't tweet." Additionally, the owner defended the removal of a fan displaying a "Fire Stearns" sign from a recent game—a decision that reflects organizational defensiveness during a period of operational strain. Cohen indicated via social media that he would address media concerns and team performance directly in the coming period, signaling an attempt to reassert leadership and stakeholder communication as the season spirals further downward.
The organization's operational difficulties intensified when Cohen made the decision to terminate manager Carlos Mendoza following a fourth consecutive series loss, including a Saturday defeat to the Philadelphia Phillies. This move, orchestrated alongside President of Baseball Operations David Stearns, represents a significant tactical shift mid-season but has failed to arrest the cascade of negative sentiment surrounding the franchise. The Mets' historical record under Cohen's ownership further complicates the narrative: since 2020, the organization has made the playoffs on only two occasions despite aggressive offseason spending directed by Stearns and Cohen jointly.
Cohen himself became the focus of organizational turbulence when he engaged directly on social media to address both legitimate team criticism and a targeted antisemitic insult. Responding on X to an expletive-laden post attacking his faith, Cohen wrote: "Thanks for reminding me why I shouldn't tweet." Additionally, the owner defended the removal of a fan displaying a "Fire Stearns" sign from a recent game—a decision that reflects organizational defensiveness during a period of operational strain. Cohen indicated via social media that he would address media concerns and team performance directly in the coming period, signaling an attempt to reassert leadership and stakeholder communication as the season spirals further downward.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.