Key Takeaways
- • NYCERS Board Votes to Exit Hedge Funds: The New York City Employees' Retirement System (NYCERS), the city's largest public employee pension fund with $51.2–$55 billion in total assets, voted Thursday to liquidate its hedge fund portfolio "as soon as practicable," representing a significant departure from the hedge fund industry.
- • Portfolio Size Under Liquidation: NYCERS is pulling between $1.5–$1.7 billion in hedge fund investments, which represents approximately 2.8% of the pension fund's total assets.
- • Joins Broader Pension Fund Exodus: NYCERS' decision follows a growing trend among public pension funds divesting from hedge funds, signaling institutional investor skepticism about hedge fund performance and fee structures.
- • Industry Headwinds: The broader hedge fund sector faced significant outflows, with eVestment data showing $19.8 billion in net redemptions across the industry in January 2016 alone—the largest monthly outflow since 2009.
- • Future Private Equity Review: In addition to the hedge fund liquidation, NYCERS trustees weighed similar action regarding private equity investments, suggesting broader portfolio reassessment.
Summary
New York City's largest public employee pension fund took decisive action on April 10, 2016, when the NYCERS board of trustees voted to exit its hedge fund investments and redirect capital to other asset classes. The resolution authorized the fund's asset managers to cease all future hedge fund allocations and liquidate existing holdings as expeditiously as possible.
NYCERS manages approximately $51.2–$55 billion in total assets for New York City civil employees. The hedge fund portfolio slated for liquidation represents between $1.5–$1.7 billion, or roughly 2.8% of the pension fund's asset base. While the hedge allocation constitutes a modest percentage of total assets, the decision carries symbolic weight given NYCERS' prominence as one of the nation's largest public pension systems and its investment profile dating back to 2010.
The NYCERS action reflects a substantial shift in how institutional investors—particularly large public pension funds—are reassessing hedge fund exposure. According to eVestment research, institutional investors collectively withdrew $19.8 billion from hedge funds in January 2016 alone, marking the largest monthly outflow since the 2009 financial crisis. This pattern demonstrates accelerating skepticism about hedge fund fee structures, alpha generation, and performance relative to alternative allocation strategies.
Beyond hedge funds, NYCERS trustees also examined whether similar liquidation actions should apply to private equity holdings, indicating a comprehensive review of alternative asset classes. The pension fund's decision to divest from hedge funds while evaluating private equity suggests trustees are prioritizing liquidity, cost efficiency, and more transparent fee arrangements as investment priorities.
NYCERS joins a growing cohort of major public pension systems opting to reduce or eliminate hedge fund exposure, reflecting a broader institutional reassessment of alternative investments in an environment of elevated fees and moderated returns.
NYCERS manages approximately $51.2–$55 billion in total assets for New York City civil employees. The hedge fund portfolio slated for liquidation represents between $1.5–$1.7 billion, or roughly 2.8% of the pension fund's asset base. While the hedge allocation constitutes a modest percentage of total assets, the decision carries symbolic weight given NYCERS' prominence as one of the nation's largest public pension systems and its investment profile dating back to 2010.
The NYCERS action reflects a substantial shift in how institutional investors—particularly large public pension funds—are reassessing hedge fund exposure. According to eVestment research, institutional investors collectively withdrew $19.8 billion from hedge funds in January 2016 alone, marking the largest monthly outflow since the 2009 financial crisis. This pattern demonstrates accelerating skepticism about hedge fund fee structures, alpha generation, and performance relative to alternative allocation strategies.
Beyond hedge funds, NYCERS trustees also examined whether similar liquidation actions should apply to private equity holdings, indicating a comprehensive review of alternative asset classes. The pension fund's decision to divest from hedge funds while evaluating private equity suggests trustees are prioritizing liquidity, cost efficiency, and more transparent fee arrangements as investment priorities.
NYCERS joins a growing cohort of major public pension systems opting to reduce or eliminate hedge fund exposure, reflecting a broader institutional reassessment of alternative investments in an environment of elevated fees and moderated returns.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.