Key Takeaways
- • Hedge fund managers exhibiting psychopathic personality traits delivered annual returns that underperformed peers by approximately 1%, translating to 15% lower cumulative returns over a decade, according to research published in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin.
- • A study of 101 male hedge fund managers with an average of $4.6 billion under management found that those with pronounced "dark triad" traits—psychopathy, narcissism, and Machiavellianism—produced inferior investment performance, contradicting the prevailing assumption that such traits correlate with professional success.
- • Researchers detected personality traits by analyzing video footage of fund managers discussing strategy and performance, observing behavioral markers including jaw thrust, flirting actions, and pronoun usage ("I" versus "we"), raising methodological questions about the research approach.
- • The study's authors concluded that while psychopathic traits may facilitate initial advancement to senior positions, they subsequently impair performance in top management roles, resulting in tangible wealth destruction for investors allocating capital to such managers.
Summary
A new study challenges the widespread assumption that psychopathic personality traits correlate with financial success in hedge fund management. Researchers published findings in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin showing that fund managers with pronounced psychopathic characteristics underperformed their peers by approximately 1% annually—a difference that compounds to 15% lower cumulative returns over a decade. For investors, this translates directly to diminished portfolio value: "An investor would see less money in their bank account at the end of a given time period if they had allocated their funds to a more psychopathic manager," according to the study's authors.
The research analyzed 101 male hedge fund managers overseeing an average of $4.6 billion in assets. Rather than conducting clinical diagnoses, researchers evaluated video footage of fund managers discussing their strategies and performance, searching for behavioral indicators associated with what psychologists term the "dark triad": psychopathy, narcissism, and Machiavellianism. Observed markers included physical behaviors such as jaw thrust and lip-licking, as well as linguistic patterns favoring first-person singular pronouns over collective language.
The findings reveal a critical distinction between reaching executive positions and performing effectively within them. While psychopathic traits—characterized by emotional detachment, impulsivity, aggression, manipulation, and lack of empathy—may facilitate ascension to leadership roles, the data indicates such individuals subsequently underdeliver in portfolio management. The authors noted that their results "undermine the assumption that psychopaths tend to be more successful," challenging conventional wisdom that ruthlessness and emotional detachment constitute advantages in competitive investment environments.
The study also identified performance impacts from narcissistic tendencies. Managers with greater narcissistic traits required riskier investment decisions to achieve comparable returns relative to less narcissistic counterparts, introducing additional portfolio volatility without corresponding alpha generation. This finding has practical implications for institutional investors conducting manager due diligence and selection processes, suggesting that personality assessment warrants consideration alongside traditional performance metrics and risk analysis in hedge fund manager evaluation.
The research analyzed 101 male hedge fund managers overseeing an average of $4.6 billion in assets. Rather than conducting clinical diagnoses, researchers evaluated video footage of fund managers discussing their strategies and performance, searching for behavioral indicators associated with what psychologists term the "dark triad": psychopathy, narcissism, and Machiavellianism. Observed markers included physical behaviors such as jaw thrust and lip-licking, as well as linguistic patterns favoring first-person singular pronouns over collective language.
The findings reveal a critical distinction between reaching executive positions and performing effectively within them. While psychopathic traits—characterized by emotional detachment, impulsivity, aggression, manipulation, and lack of empathy—may facilitate ascension to leadership roles, the data indicates such individuals subsequently underdeliver in portfolio management. The authors noted that their results "undermine the assumption that psychopaths tend to be more successful," challenging conventional wisdom that ruthlessness and emotional detachment constitute advantages in competitive investment environments.
The study also identified performance impacts from narcissistic tendencies. Managers with greater narcissistic traits required riskier investment decisions to achieve comparable returns relative to less narcissistic counterparts, introducing additional portfolio volatility without corresponding alpha generation. This finding has practical implications for institutional investors conducting manager due diligence and selection processes, suggesting that personality assessment warrants consideration alongside traditional performance metrics and risk analysis in hedge fund manager evaluation.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.