Key Takeaways
- • Orange County Employees Retirement System (OCERS), a $21 billion California pension fund, is considering dropping Bridgewater Associates' Pure Alpha fund after 16+ years of underperformance relative to its benchmark, with annualized returns of 4.5% versus a target 2.5 percentage points higher.
- • Pure Alpha has outperformed OCERS's target only once in the last five years and has underperformed across seven- and 10-year periods, prompting the pension's CIO Molly Murphy to recommend placing the fund on a formal watch list, a move supported by investment consultant Meketa Investment Group.
- • Bridgewater lost $12.1 billion for investors in 2020, a year when the world's top 20 hedge funds achieved their best returns in a decade, highlighting the fund's significant performance divergence from industry peers.
- • Pure Alpha represents approximately 10% of OCERS's risk mitigation asset class and $175 million of Bridgewater's $105 billion in hedge fund assets under management, indicating the pension's position is material but not transformative to the firm at an enterprise level.
- • Placement on a watch list does not guarantee divestment, though the recommendation underscores sustained performance challenges and investor scrutiny of hedge fund fees and returns in an increasingly competitive institutional asset management landscape.
Summary
The Orange County Employees Retirement System, managing $21 billion in pension assets, is evaluating whether to terminate its investment in Bridgewater Associates' flagship Pure Alpha fund following more than a decade of persistent underperformance. According to a memo from Meketa Investment Group, OCERS's investment consultant, Pure Alpha has delivered annualized returns of 4.5% since the pension's initial investment in 2005—roughly 2.5 percentage points below its stated benchmark. This performance gap has widened in recent years, with the fund outperforming OCERS's target in only one of the last five years and lagging across both seven- and 10-year measurement horizons.
OCERS's Chief Investment Officer Molly Murphy has formally recommended placing Pure Alpha on the pension's watch list, a recommendation that Meketa consultants endorsed. This designation signals heightened scrutiny but does not immediately trigger divestment; however, it establishes a formal review pathway that could lead to the fund's removal. Within OCERS's portfolio construction, Pure Alpha comprises approximately 10% of its risk mitigation asset class allocation, making it a material but not dominant holding.
Bridgewater's recent performance challenges extend beyond OCERS's experience. In 2020, Dalio's firm posted a $12.1 billion loss for investors during a year when the world's top 20 hedge funds achieved their best returns in a decade—a striking performance discrepancy that intensified investor concerns about the fund's strategy and execution. Despite these recent struggles, Ray Dalio remains regarded as the best-performing hedge fund manager of all time according to LCH Investments, a distinction that reflects his historical track record even as current performance disappoints institutional clients.
From an asset management perspective, OCERS's $175 million allocation represents a modest percentage of Bridgewater's $105 billion in hedge fund assets under management, suggesting that the potential loss of this institutional client, while symbolically significant, would not materially impact Bridgewater's enterprise scale. Nonetheless, OCERS's reconsideration reflects broader institutional skepticism regarding hedge fund fee structures and performance sustainability, particularly among large pension funds that increasingly demand consistent outperformance relative to stated benchmarks and mandates.
OCERS's Chief Investment Officer Molly Murphy has formally recommended placing Pure Alpha on the pension's watch list, a recommendation that Meketa consultants endorsed. This designation signals heightened scrutiny but does not immediately trigger divestment; however, it establishes a formal review pathway that could lead to the fund's removal. Within OCERS's portfolio construction, Pure Alpha comprises approximately 10% of its risk mitigation asset class allocation, making it a material but not dominant holding.
Bridgewater's recent performance challenges extend beyond OCERS's experience. In 2020, Dalio's firm posted a $12.1 billion loss for investors during a year when the world's top 20 hedge funds achieved their best returns in a decade—a striking performance discrepancy that intensified investor concerns about the fund's strategy and execution. Despite these recent struggles, Ray Dalio remains regarded as the best-performing hedge fund manager of all time according to LCH Investments, a distinction that reflects his historical track record even as current performance disappoints institutional clients.
From an asset management perspective, OCERS's $175 million allocation represents a modest percentage of Bridgewater's $105 billion in hedge fund assets under management, suggesting that the potential loss of this institutional client, while symbolically significant, would not materially impact Bridgewater's enterprise scale. Nonetheless, OCERS's reconsideration reflects broader institutional skepticism regarding hedge fund fee structures and performance sustainability, particularly among large pension funds that increasingly demand consistent outperformance relative to stated benchmarks and mandates.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.