Key Takeaways
- • Stearns' Job Secured: Mets owner Steve Cohen publicly committed to retaining David Stearns as president of baseball operations, stating Stearns will "live out" his five-year contract through the 2028 season despite intense performance pressure.
- • Organizational Accountability: Cohen indicated that while Stearns remains in place, management changes will occur elsewhere—specifically following the firing of manager Carlos Mendoza—signaling a distinction between front-office stability and field-level accountability.
- • Roster Restructuring Backfired: The Mets' aggressive offseason moves to rebuild (trading Brandon Nimmo for Marcus Semien, letting Pete Alonso depart to Baltimore) have underperformed significantly, with key acquisitions either injured or hitting substantially below expectations.
- • Performance Context: The Mets' 2026 season represents a continuation of organizational struggles following their collapse in late 2025, when the team dropped from contention after leading MLB through the first three months and missed the postseason entirely.
- • Cohen's Confidence in Leadership: Despite the team's disappointing trajectory, Cohen characterized Stearns as "reflective and adaptable," indicating ownership's belief in the executive's capacity to course-correct strategy going forward.
Summary
Mets owner Steve Cohen made unambiguous public statements affirming David Stearns' job security as president of baseball operations, ending speculation about the executive's tenure following another disappointing season for the franchise. Speaking on The Show podcast in his first public comments since firing manager Carlos Mendoza, Cohen stated: "David is reflective and adaptable. We'll figure out what changes need to be made, but it won't be David." Cohen further committed that Stearns would "live out" the remainder of his five-year contract through the 2028 season.
The affirmation comes amid a chaotic operational period for the organization. The Mets entered 2025 as one of baseball's best teams through June but collapsed dramatically over the final three-and-a-half months, resulting in a complete postseason miss. In response, Stearns oversaw substantial roster turnover: the organization allowed slugger Pete Alonso to leave in free agency to the Baltimore Orioles and traded outfielder Brandon Nimmo to the Texas Rangers in exchange for infielder Marcus Semien. These moves were designed to reshape the roster and inject new talent into critical positions.
However, the corresponding acquisitions have significantly underperformed. Semien landed on the injured list with a hip issue after posting a .214 batting average and .613 on-base-plus-slugging percentage across 290 at-bats in limited action. Jorge Polanco, acquired as a middle-infield solution but transitioning to first base, has been sidelined since April with an ankle injury, recording a .179 average before his IL placement. Third baseman Bo Bichette, signed to a three-year contract, started poorly with a batting average 60 points below his prior-season mark. The combination of injuries and offensive production shortfalls has created substantial roster dysfunction.
Cohen's decision to retain Stearns while firing Mendoza suggests a deliberate separation between front-office accountability and field management responsibility. This bifurcation indicates ownership's diagnosis of performance problems extends beyond scouting and roster construction to in-game execution and coaching. Stearns, now in his third season of his five-year contract with the Mets, remains tasked with reconstructing a competitive roster despite recent strategic missteps, though Cohen's public confidence signals the ownership group believes the executive possesses the adaptability required to correct course.
The affirmation comes amid a chaotic operational period for the organization. The Mets entered 2025 as one of baseball's best teams through June but collapsed dramatically over the final three-and-a-half months, resulting in a complete postseason miss. In response, Stearns oversaw substantial roster turnover: the organization allowed slugger Pete Alonso to leave in free agency to the Baltimore Orioles and traded outfielder Brandon Nimmo to the Texas Rangers in exchange for infielder Marcus Semien. These moves were designed to reshape the roster and inject new talent into critical positions.
However, the corresponding acquisitions have significantly underperformed. Semien landed on the injured list with a hip issue after posting a .214 batting average and .613 on-base-plus-slugging percentage across 290 at-bats in limited action. Jorge Polanco, acquired as a middle-infield solution but transitioning to first base, has been sidelined since April with an ankle injury, recording a .179 average before his IL placement. Third baseman Bo Bichette, signed to a three-year contract, started poorly with a batting average 60 points below his prior-season mark. The combination of injuries and offensive production shortfalls has created substantial roster dysfunction.
Cohen's decision to retain Stearns while firing Mendoza suggests a deliberate separation between front-office accountability and field management responsibility. This bifurcation indicates ownership's diagnosis of performance problems extends beyond scouting and roster construction to in-game execution and coaching. Stearns, now in his third season of his five-year contract with the Mets, remains tasked with reconstructing a competitive roster despite recent strategic missteps, though Cohen's public confidence signals the ownership group believes the executive possesses the adaptability required to correct course.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.