Key Takeaways
- • Morningstar's hedge fund index tracking shows the Morningstar 1000 HF USD index returned 3.16% year-to-date and 6.11% over a longer period as of August 24, 2009, providing institutional investors with benchmarking data during the post-financial crisis recovery period.
- • The Morningstar Hedge Fund of Funds index posted more modest returns of 0.68% year-to-date and 5.34% over the comparative period, underperforming the broader hedge fund index and reflecting manager selection challenges during market volatility.
- • Morningstar's index data serves as a critical performance measurement tool for pension funds and institutional allocators evaluating hedge fund exposure during a period of significant market dislocation and manager stress.
Summary
Morningstar published hedge fund index return data as of August 2009, tracking performance metrics relevant to institutional investors navigating the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis. The Morningstar 1000 HF USD index, a broad measure of hedge fund performance, delivered 3.16% year-to-date returns and 6.11% over the extended measurement period. This benchmarking index represents a significant cross-section of hedge fund strategies and serves as a standard reference point for pension plans and institutional allocators evaluating hedge fund portfolio positioning.
In comparison, the Morningstar Hedge Fund of Funds index—which tracks vehicles that allocate capital across multiple underlying hedge funds—returned 0.68% year-to-date with 5.34% for the longer period. The meaningful performance gap between the broad hedge fund index and the fund-of-funds index reflects the structural challenges and manager selection difficulties that institutional investors faced in 2009, when many secondary managers underperformed primary strategy exposure. This divergence underscores the increased importance of manager selection discipline during periods of market stress, a theme consistent with institutional investor feedback from the period.
These indices provided critical data for pension funds and family offices reassessing hedge fund allocations during a turbulent market environment. Morningstar's ongoing publication of hedge fund index returns enabled sophisticated investors to benchmark their direct hedge fund exposure against industry standards and evaluate the value proposition of fund-of-funds vehicles as an alternative to direct manager selection.
In comparison, the Morningstar Hedge Fund of Funds index—which tracks vehicles that allocate capital across multiple underlying hedge funds—returned 0.68% year-to-date with 5.34% for the longer period. The meaningful performance gap between the broad hedge fund index and the fund-of-funds index reflects the structural challenges and manager selection difficulties that institutional investors faced in 2009, when many secondary managers underperformed primary strategy exposure. This divergence underscores the increased importance of manager selection discipline during periods of market stress, a theme consistent with institutional investor feedback from the period.
These indices provided critical data for pension funds and family offices reassessing hedge fund allocations during a turbulent market environment. Morningstar's ongoing publication of hedge fund index returns enabled sophisticated investors to benchmark their direct hedge fund exposure against industry standards and evaluate the value proposition of fund-of-funds vehicles as an alternative to direct manager selection.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.