Key Takeaways
- • Investment consultants at Aon are advising institutional asset owners to implement tail-risk protection strategies in response to elevated inflation, market volatility, and recession concerns as of January 2023.
- • Aon's preferred approach prioritizes building inherently resilient portfolios through strategic allocation to "true" diversifying assets rather than relying solely on purchased equity options, which may prove too costly to maintain through market cycles.
- • Safe haven assets including US Treasuries, the US dollar, Japanese yen, and gold are recommended as core portfolio components to protect against downside risks in the current market environment.
- • Consultants warn that asset owners purchasing tail-risk protection via options face the risk of abandoning these expensive hedges before they are needed, potentially leaving portfolios unprotected during crisis events.
- • Risk premia are becoming more attractive following repricing, but near-term uncertainty continues to warrant reduced exposure to equity and credit risk alongside increased portfolio diversification.
Summary
Investment consultants are actively recommending that institutional asset owners incorporate tail-risk protection into their portfolios amid persistent macroeconomic headwinds, according to Aon senior portfolio manager Guy Saintfiet. As of January 2023, elevated inflation, sustained market volatility, and mounting recession risks have prompted a material increase in institutional demand for downside protection strategies.
Saintfiet emphasizes that while risk premia "look more attractive as risk has been repriced," the near-term environment still warrants a defensive posture. He advises clients to "reduce their market sensitivity to equity and credit risk and add more diversification and protection to the portfolio," reflecting broad consultant consensus that strategic asset allocation adjustments are necessary for the current market regime.
Aon advocates for a primary strategy centered on building portfolios that are inherently "more resilient" through intentional strategic allocation to diversifying assets, rather than through tactical purchases of equity options. This approach reflects a fundamental critique of conventional tail-risk hedging: options-based protection tends to be prohibitively expensive to hold through full market cycles, creating a behavioral risk that asset owners will abandon hedges before they are most needed. As Saintfiet cautions, the cost burden raises the risk that institutional investors "won't have the staying power to keep these assets, and then when [they] need it [they] don't have the protection."
To construct naturally diversifying portfolios, consultants direct asset owners toward traditional safe haven assets—US Treasuries, the US dollar, Japanese yen, and gold. These assets have historically exhibited low or negative correlation with equities during stress periods, providing structural downside protection without the behavioral and cost challenges associated with derivatives-based hedging.
Saintfiet emphasizes that while risk premia "look more attractive as risk has been repriced," the near-term environment still warrants a defensive posture. He advises clients to "reduce their market sensitivity to equity and credit risk and add more diversification and protection to the portfolio," reflecting broad consultant consensus that strategic asset allocation adjustments are necessary for the current market regime.
Aon advocates for a primary strategy centered on building portfolios that are inherently "more resilient" through intentional strategic allocation to diversifying assets, rather than through tactical purchases of equity options. This approach reflects a fundamental critique of conventional tail-risk hedging: options-based protection tends to be prohibitively expensive to hold through full market cycles, creating a behavioral risk that asset owners will abandon hedges before they are most needed. As Saintfiet cautions, the cost burden raises the risk that institutional investors "won't have the staying power to keep these assets, and then when [they] need it [they] don't have the protection."
To construct naturally diversifying portfolios, consultants direct asset owners toward traditional safe haven assets—US Treasuries, the US dollar, Japanese yen, and gold. These assets have historically exhibited low or negative correlation with equities during stress periods, providing structural downside protection without the behavioral and cost challenges associated with derivatives-based hedging.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.