Key Takeaways
- • Global hedge funds experienced $29.2bn in third-quarter redemptions, with September alone accounting for $10.3bn—the largest outflow since the 2009 financial crisis panic withdrawals, according to eVestment research vice-president Peter Laurelli.
- • South African hedge funds are bucking the global trend, with the sector showing relative resilience while core strategies worldwide face severe capital flight: long/short equity lost nearly $9bn and market neutral funds saw $1bn in outflows during Q3.
- • Managed futures is the only primary hedge fund strategy attracting meaningful capital, with $6.35bn in inflows during the September quarter, even as the last managed futures fund in South Africa recently closed, creating a potential market opportunity.
- • Distressed debt and event-driven strategies shed $6bn and $2.6bn respectively in the quarter, while commodity funds posted a $620m outflow despite year-to-date gains of $11.2bn, reflecting persistent investor hesitation across traditional alternative strategies.
- • eVestment data shows five of nine months in 2016 saw more than half of hedge funds recording net outflows, indicating slow but sustained asset erosion across the broader industry.
Summary
The global hedge fund industry is experiencing significant capital withdrawal that mirrors post-crisis stress levels not seen since early 2009. Third-quarter redemptions totaled $29.2bn, with September alone recording $10.3bn in outflows—more than twice the size of the entire South African hedge fund industry combined. This represents the sharpest monthly exodus since panic withdrawals followed the Lehman Brothers collapse, according to data cited from Peter Laurelli, vice-president of research at eVestment, the dominant hedge fund research and analytics firm.
The flight from traditional hedge fund strategies has been particularly acute. The two foundational strategy pillars—long/short equity and market neutral funds—experienced severe capital depletion, with the former losing nearly $9bn and the latter withdrawing $1bn during the quarter. Event-driven strategies, including merger arbitrage, shed $2.6bn, while distressed debt funds lost $6bn. Even commodity funds, which have benefited from recent sector revival, posted a $620m outflow, though they remain $11.2bn positive year-to-date.
In marked contrast to global trends, South African hedge funds are demonstrating relative stability, defying the broader market pattern. The divergence is significant given the size disparity: September's global monthly outflows dwarf the entire South African hedge fund sector. However, the South African market faces its own challenges. The last managed futures fund in the country recently closed, yet Laurelli identifies managed futures as the sole primary strategy attracting meaningful capital allocation, with $6.35bn in inflows during the September quarter—suggesting a potential opportunity for new entrants to capture this niche.
Laurelli's analysis reveals persistent asset erosion: in five of nine months during 2016, more than half of all hedge funds recorded net outflows. This pattern indicates structural headwinds rather than temporary volatility, prompting questions about whether traditional hedge fund vehicles remain aligned with institutional investor preferences in the current market environment.
The flight from traditional hedge fund strategies has been particularly acute. The two foundational strategy pillars—long/short equity and market neutral funds—experienced severe capital depletion, with the former losing nearly $9bn and the latter withdrawing $1bn during the quarter. Event-driven strategies, including merger arbitrage, shed $2.6bn, while distressed debt funds lost $6bn. Even commodity funds, which have benefited from recent sector revival, posted a $620m outflow, though they remain $11.2bn positive year-to-date.
In marked contrast to global trends, South African hedge funds are demonstrating relative stability, defying the broader market pattern. The divergence is significant given the size disparity: September's global monthly outflows dwarf the entire South African hedge fund sector. However, the South African market faces its own challenges. The last managed futures fund in the country recently closed, yet Laurelli identifies managed futures as the sole primary strategy attracting meaningful capital allocation, with $6.35bn in inflows during the September quarter—suggesting a potential opportunity for new entrants to capture this niche.
Laurelli's analysis reveals persistent asset erosion: in five of nine months during 2016, more than half of all hedge funds recorded net outflows. This pattern indicates structural headwinds rather than temporary volatility, prompting questions about whether traditional hedge fund vehicles remain aligned with institutional investor preferences in the current market environment.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.