Key Takeaways
- • BlackRock explains that paid-in-kind (PIK) interest accrues to a loan's principal rather than being paid in cash, and is typically priced at a premium to cash interest to compensate investors for the deferred payout.
- • BlackRock argues PIK has shifted from public high yield toward private credit, where direct negotiation allows greater structuring flexibility; PIK issuance as a share of U.S. high yield issuance declined across the 2007-2008, 2013 and 2018-2020 episodes.
- • The firm characterizes PIK as "good" when structured thoughtfully as a liquidity tool for performing companies, and "bad" when it masks deteriorating fundamentals, a distinction it says investors and managers should weigh.
- • BlackRock notes that BDCs must distribute 90% of interest income to investors, constraining PIK use within those vehicles, while CLOs generally cap PIK-eligible assets at 5% or less.
Summary
BlackRock's primer on paid-in-kind (PIK) interest describes the feature as interest that is added to the outstanding principal balance of a loan or bond rather than paid in cash as it accrues. Because of the deferred payout, PIK is typically priced at a premium to cash interest, and limits are commonly placed on how long a borrower may defer cash payments and what portion of the rate may be PIK. The article identifies three structures: full PIK, partial PIK, and PIK toggle, where the borrower may switch between cash and PIK if conditions are met. BlackRock illustrates the trade-off using a hypothetical $500 million fixed-rate investment, where greater PIK use preserves near-term cash flow while increasing debt over time.
The firm says PIK gained attention as the Federal Reserve raised base rates by 500 basis points over four quarters between 2022 and 2023, which in some cases more than doubled cash interest owed by businesses. BlackRock also notes that interest, including PIK, is generally tax deductible in most jurisdictions. Historically, PIK has been common in private credit and selectively used in high yield during volatility; BlackRock reports that PIK made up 14% and 19% of U.S. high yield issuance in 2007 and 2008, and that its share declined across successive cycles, which it attributes in part to private credit growth. It did not observe a comparable PIK spike in high yield during the 2022-2023 tightening.
BlackRock states that private credit BDC assets can serve as a proxy for the broader market, which it says holds an additional roughly $1.6 trillion outside BDCs. PIK is generally unavailable in the broadly syndicated loan market due to CLO constraints. The article also addresses junior capital, which sits between first-lien senior secured debt and common equity, and where PIK flexibility is typically structured upfront. BlackRock argues this can help companies de-lever senior debt and improve coverage ratios. In senior loans, PIK usually applies only to part of the spread, often for 18-24 months. The article concludes that private credit managers typically earn an economic premium for offering this flexibility.
The firm says PIK gained attention as the Federal Reserve raised base rates by 500 basis points over four quarters between 2022 and 2023, which in some cases more than doubled cash interest owed by businesses. BlackRock also notes that interest, including PIK, is generally tax deductible in most jurisdictions. Historically, PIK has been common in private credit and selectively used in high yield during volatility; BlackRock reports that PIK made up 14% and 19% of U.S. high yield issuance in 2007 and 2008, and that its share declined across successive cycles, which it attributes in part to private credit growth. It did not observe a comparable PIK spike in high yield during the 2022-2023 tightening.
BlackRock states that private credit BDC assets can serve as a proxy for the broader market, which it says holds an additional roughly $1.6 trillion outside BDCs. PIK is generally unavailable in the broadly syndicated loan market due to CLO constraints. The article also addresses junior capital, which sits between first-lien senior secured debt and common equity, and where PIK flexibility is typically structured upfront. BlackRock argues this can help companies de-lever senior debt and improve coverage ratios. In senior loans, PIK usually applies only to part of the spread, often for 18-24 months. The article concludes that private credit managers typically earn an economic premium for offering this flexibility.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.