Key Takeaways
- • Omnigence Asset Management released a white paper arguing that Distributions to Paid-In Capital (DPI) is emerging as a critical performance validation metric alongside Internal Rate of Return (IRR) in private equity evaluation, reflecting structural market shifts toward realized outcomes over unrealized valuations.
- • IRR's traditional dominance as the primary private equity benchmark is being challenged by prolonged holding periods, constrained exit markets, and extended periods of unrealized valuations, prompting Limited Partners to recalibrate their evaluation frameworks.
- • The paper presents DPI and IRR as complementary performance measures rather than competing metrics, advocating for an integrated approach that balances return potential with demonstrable cash distributions to investors.
- • Limited Partners are increasingly prioritizing realized distributions and liquidity visibility as liquidity conditions tighten across private markets, signaling a fundamental shift in how allocators assess private equity fund performance.
- • Omnigence, a Canadian alternative investment platform with operations in Toronto and Calgary, specializes in farmland, operational private equity, and secondaries, positioning itself within the broader context of this performance evaluation evolution.
Summary
Omnigence Asset Management has released a white paper titled "DPI as the New IRR: Updating the Performance Evaluation of Private Equity for Allocators," examining how private equity performance assessment is fundamentally shifting in response to prolonged holding periods, constrained exit environments, and mounting skepticism toward valuation-based metrics. The January 26, 2026 release reflects growing institutional concern about the adequacy of traditional performance measurement frameworks in today's market conditions.
For decades, Internal Rate of Return has been the industry standard for evaluating private equity performance. However, as liquidity conditions tighten and portfolio companies remain unrealized for extended periods, allocators are increasingly demanding clarity on realized cash outcomes. Omnigence's analysis identifies this transition, arguing that Distributions to Paid-In Capital—which measures actual cash returned to investors relative to capital deployed—provides essential transparency that IRR alone cannot deliver in environments characterized by extended holding periods and valuation uncertainty.
The white paper articulates the structural limitations of IRR in the current market environment, particularly as unrealized valuations persist longer and exit markets remain constrained. Rather than replacing IRR, the paper advocates treating DPI and IRR as complementary measures. This integrated approach would allow Limited Partners to assess both return potential and realized outcomes, addressing the dual concern of demonstrable performance and remaining portfolio value. The analysis draws on current market data and industry research to support the case for this recalibration.
Limited Partners globally are actively recalibrating their evaluation frameworks to prioritize demonstrable distributions, reflecting heightened scrutiny of mark-to-market valuations and a structural preference for transparency on actual capital returned. This shift has significant implications for how fund managers position performance, how allocators assess track records, and ultimately how capital flows within the alternative investment ecosystem.
Omnigence, which operates from offices in Toronto and Calgary, specializes in farmland, operational private equity, and secondaries. The firm positions itself as serving investors seeking to preserve purchasing power and build durable portfolios amid a structurally challenging macroeconomic environment. The full white paper is available in the Insights section of the firm's website.
For decades, Internal Rate of Return has been the industry standard for evaluating private equity performance. However, as liquidity conditions tighten and portfolio companies remain unrealized for extended periods, allocators are increasingly demanding clarity on realized cash outcomes. Omnigence's analysis identifies this transition, arguing that Distributions to Paid-In Capital—which measures actual cash returned to investors relative to capital deployed—provides essential transparency that IRR alone cannot deliver in environments characterized by extended holding periods and valuation uncertainty.
The white paper articulates the structural limitations of IRR in the current market environment, particularly as unrealized valuations persist longer and exit markets remain constrained. Rather than replacing IRR, the paper advocates treating DPI and IRR as complementary measures. This integrated approach would allow Limited Partners to assess both return potential and realized outcomes, addressing the dual concern of demonstrable performance and remaining portfolio value. The analysis draws on current market data and industry research to support the case for this recalibration.
Limited Partners globally are actively recalibrating their evaluation frameworks to prioritize demonstrable distributions, reflecting heightened scrutiny of mark-to-market valuations and a structural preference for transparency on actual capital returned. This shift has significant implications for how fund managers position performance, how allocators assess track records, and ultimately how capital flows within the alternative investment ecosystem.
Omnigence, which operates from offices in Toronto and Calgary, specializes in farmland, operational private equity, and secondaries. The firm positions itself as serving investors seeking to preserve purchasing power and build durable portfolios amid a structurally challenging macroeconomic environment. The full white paper is available in the Insights section of the firm's website.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.