Key Takeaways
- • Orlando Bravo and Thoma Bravo are repositioning the Miami-based private equity firm to compete in the AI era, following a >$5 billion loss on Medallia (online customer survey platform) that has raised investor concerns about portfolio stress and deal selection discipline.
- • Software's share of U.S. buyout deal value peaked at ~20% in 2022 before declining to ~13% in 2023, signaling a structural shift in the sector that demands strategic adaptation from Thoma Bravo, historically a software-focused powerhouse.
- • Thoma Bravo portfolio companies are generating 50% of new revenue from AI and agentic tools, demonstrating the firm's active repositioning of existing assets; however, Bravo has warned that AI valuations may be unsustainably elevated across the market.
- • The Medallia underperformance is being positioned by management as an isolated incident; however, investor vigilance remains elevated as the fund lags behind competing firms and the broader market reassesses software buyout fundamentals in a high-rate, AI-disrupted environment.
Summary
Orlando Bravo built Thoma Bravo into a private equity powerhouse by making early, lucrative bets on software as a transformative investment theme. That strategic insight delivered substantial returns and transformed Bravo into a billionaire. However, the same industry dynamics that fueled his success are now forcing a fundamental repositioning of his firm's strategy and investor messaging.
The catalysts for this shift are twofold: a dramatic >$5 billion loss on Medallia, an online customer survey platform, and the structural decline of software as a percentage of U.S. buyout deal value. According to PitchBook data cited in reporting, software represented approximately 8% of U.S. buyout deal value in 2015, surged to a peak of roughly 20% in 2022, then retreated to approximately 13% in 2023. This contraction reflects broader sector challenges, including valuation compression, rising interest rates, and the emergence of artificial intelligence as both an opportunity and a disruptive threat to traditional software economics.
Management is actively responding to these headwinds. Thoma Bravo portfolio companies are now generating 50% of new revenue from AI and agentic tools, demonstrating that the firm is not passively waiting for disruption but actively upgrading its asset base. Bravo himself has publicly stated that he believes AI is boosting software companies broadly, though he has also cautioned that market sentiment reflects excessive valuations in some AI segments.
The Medallia loss has become the central test of investor confidence. Management is characterizing it as a one-off event rather than a symptom of deeper portfolio stress, but investor vigilance remains acute. The fund holding Medallia is currently lagging behind rival firms, and limited partners are closely monitoring for additional stressed or underperforming assets. Bravo's task is clear: reassure investors that Thoma Bravo has adapted to the AI era, that legacy software bets are being repositioned effectively, and that the firm's capital allocation discipline remains intact despite a visible misfire. The success of this repositioning effort will likely determine whether Thoma Bravo maintains its status as an industry leader or faces sustained capital commitments constraints from existing and prospective institutional investors.
The catalysts for this shift are twofold: a dramatic >$5 billion loss on Medallia, an online customer survey platform, and the structural decline of software as a percentage of U.S. buyout deal value. According to PitchBook data cited in reporting, software represented approximately 8% of U.S. buyout deal value in 2015, surged to a peak of roughly 20% in 2022, then retreated to approximately 13% in 2023. This contraction reflects broader sector challenges, including valuation compression, rising interest rates, and the emergence of artificial intelligence as both an opportunity and a disruptive threat to traditional software economics.
Management is actively responding to these headwinds. Thoma Bravo portfolio companies are now generating 50% of new revenue from AI and agentic tools, demonstrating that the firm is not passively waiting for disruption but actively upgrading its asset base. Bravo himself has publicly stated that he believes AI is boosting software companies broadly, though he has also cautioned that market sentiment reflects excessive valuations in some AI segments.
The Medallia loss has become the central test of investor confidence. Management is characterizing it as a one-off event rather than a symptom of deeper portfolio stress, but investor vigilance remains acute. The fund holding Medallia is currently lagging behind rival firms, and limited partners are closely monitoring for additional stressed or underperforming assets. Bravo's task is clear: reassure investors that Thoma Bravo has adapted to the AI era, that legacy software bets are being repositioned effectively, and that the firm's capital allocation discipline remains intact despite a visible misfire. The success of this repositioning effort will likely determine whether Thoma Bravo maintains its status as an industry leader or faces sustained capital commitments constraints from existing and prospective institutional investors.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.