Key Takeaways
- • Thoma Bravo to surrender Medallia to lenders in restructuring that wipes out $5.1 billion in equity, transferring control of the customer experience software company to creditors including Blackstone, KKR, Apollo Global, and Antares Capital, who collectively hold $3 billion in debt.
- • Original acquisition price of $6.4 billion in 2021 reflects post-pandemic buyout bubble dynamics, when Thoma Bravo invested heavily in software during the era of near-zero interest rates, now creating a severe valuation disconnect.
- • Lenders have marked down Medallia debt significantly, with FS KKR Capital Corp valuing loans at 79 cents on the dollar and Apollo Debt Solutions at 74 cents, signaling substantial credit deterioration across private credit portfolios.
- • Business development companies face deepest NAV discounts in 5.5+ years, with median price-to-forward 12-month NAV ratio at 0.74 (26% discount) as of end-March 2026, indicating systemic stress in the private credit sector.
- • Medallia's collapse reflects execution failures rather than market headwinds, according to Blackstone's global head of private credit Brad Marshall, who attributed underperformance to operational issues unrelated to artificial intelligence.
Summary
Thoma Bravo, one of the world's largest software-focused private equity firms, is nearing agreement to cede control of Medallia, a customer experience software platform, to its lender consortium in what constitutes one of the most significant post-pandemic private equity failures. The restructuring will wipe out $5.1 billion in equity value for Thoma Bravo, which acquired the company for $6.4 billion in 2021. The transfer of control will shift to a creditor group comprising Blackstone, KKR, Apollo Global, and Antares Capital, collectively holding approximately $3 billion in Medallia debt.
The Medallia investment exemplifies the broader dynamics of the post-pandemic buyout cycle, when private equity firms deployed capital aggressively into software assets while debt financing remained abundant and cheap. Thoma Bravo's bet on the customer experience software market appeared sound during the era of near-zero interest rates, but deteriorating execution and operational challenges have rendered the investment severely impaired. Blackstone's global head of private credit Brad Marshall attributed Medallia's underperformance in February remarks to "execution-driven issues" rather than market or technology factors, explicitly noting the problems were unrelated to artificial intelligence developments.
Credit markets have already reflected the deterioration in Medallia's fundamentals. FS KKR Capital Corp marked the debt at 79 cents on the dollar in its most recent quarterly filing, while Apollo Debt Solutions valued the same obligations at just 74 cents, indicating substantial write-downs across major private credit investors. These markdowns underscore the broader stress emerging in the private credit sector as a whole.
The Medallia restructuring arrives at a critical juncture for private credit. Business development companies are currently trading at their deepest discounts to net asset value in more than 5.5 years, with the median price-to-forward 12-month NAV ratio standing at approximately 0.74 at end-March 2026—implying a roughly 26% discount and the widest spread since October 2020. This valuation pressure is particularly acute among firms with material software exposure, as the Medallia situation highlights both sector-specific risks and the consequences of leverage taken during favorable financing conditions that have since reversed.
The Medallia investment exemplifies the broader dynamics of the post-pandemic buyout cycle, when private equity firms deployed capital aggressively into software assets while debt financing remained abundant and cheap. Thoma Bravo's bet on the customer experience software market appeared sound during the era of near-zero interest rates, but deteriorating execution and operational challenges have rendered the investment severely impaired. Blackstone's global head of private credit Brad Marshall attributed Medallia's underperformance in February remarks to "execution-driven issues" rather than market or technology factors, explicitly noting the problems were unrelated to artificial intelligence developments.
Credit markets have already reflected the deterioration in Medallia's fundamentals. FS KKR Capital Corp marked the debt at 79 cents on the dollar in its most recent quarterly filing, while Apollo Debt Solutions valued the same obligations at just 74 cents, indicating substantial write-downs across major private credit investors. These markdowns underscore the broader stress emerging in the private credit sector as a whole.
The Medallia restructuring arrives at a critical juncture for private credit. Business development companies are currently trading at their deepest discounts to net asset value in more than 5.5 years, with the median price-to-forward 12-month NAV ratio standing at approximately 0.74 at end-March 2026—implying a roughly 26% discount and the widest spread since October 2020. This valuation pressure is particularly acute among firms with material software exposure, as the Medallia situation highlights both sector-specific risks and the consequences of leverage taken during favorable financing conditions that have since reversed.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.