AlphaMaven AlphaMaven

American Tower or Crown Castle? Wall Street's Clear Pick Between Beaten-Down Tower REITs - 24/7 Wall St.

Reported by 247wallst
Jul 29, 2026· 3 min read
Save Post LinkedIn Email
Key Takeaways
  • • Bernstein upgrades American Tower to Outperform with $207 price target, citing durable structural demand from 5G densification, fixed wireless access growth, and data center adjacency as tailwinds for the sector's recovery from higher rates and softer carrier spending.
  • • American Tower beat Q1 2026 earnings expectations with EPS of $1.84 versus $1.57 expected and revenue of $2.74 billion, prompting management to raise full-year AFFO guidance to $10.90–$11.07 per share and total property revenue to $10.59–$10.74 billion.
  • • Data center revenue emerged as a meaningful growth driver, increasing 18% in Q1 2026 and positioning American Tower as a diversified infrastructure play beyond traditional tower colocation.
  • • Crown Castle is executing a strategic pivot to pure-play tower REIT status through the planned divestiture of its fiber and small-cell assets (valued at $8.5 billion), creating distinct strategic profiles between the two largest U.S. tower operators.
  • • American Tower ($84.8 billion market cap) commands Wall Street preference over Crown Castle amid sector recovery, with tower REITs collectively controlling just under 100,000 towers across American Tower, Crown Castle, and SBA Communications.
Summary
Wall Street is signaling a clear preference for American Tower over Crown Castle as tower REITs recover from a challenging period marked by higher interest rates and reduced carrier capital expenditures. Bernstein Research upgraded American Tower to Outperform on July 29, 2026, with a $207 price target, representing meaningful upside from recent trading levels near $182.50. The upgrade reflects renewed confidence in the sector's structural growth drivers, including ongoing 5G network densification, fixed wireless access expansion, and emerging adjacencies to data center infrastructure.

American Tower's financial performance validates this constructive thesis. In Q1 2026, the company delivered EPS of $1.84 against consensus expectations of $1.57, while revenue reached $2.74 billion on guidance for $2.71 billion. Management subsequently raised full-year 2026 guidance, projecting adjusted funds from operations (AFFO) per share between $10.90 and $11.07, with total property revenue expected to reach $10.59 to $10.74 billion. The company's revenue base of $10.3 billion annualized positions it as the largest among the "big three" tower REITs, which collectively control just under 100,000 towers alongside Crown Castle and SBA Communications.

A critical differentiator emerging between American Tower and Crown Castle centers on strategic portfolio composition. Crown Castle is advancing a transformational shift toward becoming a pure-play tower REIT, pursuing the divestiture of its fiber and small-cell assets valued at approximately $8.5 billion. This transition represents a fundamental repositioning that creates two distinct investment theses: American Tower as a diversified infrastructure operator with meaningful data center exposure (growing 18% in Q1 2026), versus Crown Castle as a traditional tower-focused pure-play.

For institutional investors, Bernstein's rationale emphasizes declining interest rate sensitivity as Federal Reserve policy matures, coupled with durable secular demand for wireless infrastructure colocation. The sector's recovery from depressed valuations reflects both operational resilience and structural tailwinds that should support long-term cash flow generation across the portfolio. American Tower's ability to execute across both traditional tower leasing and newer data center opportunities positions it favorably relative to peers undertaking narrower strategic repositioning.

Go deeper than the headline

Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.

Start your free 7-day trial