Key Takeaways
- • The U.S. Department of Labor proposed a landmark rule on April 10, 2026, establishing process-based guidelines for 401(k) plan fiduciaries to evaluate alternative assets including private equity, real estate, and cryptocurrency, affecting investment options for more than 90 million Americans.
- • The proposed regulation introduces a safe harbor provision that limits litigation risk for plan fiduciaries who follow a six-factor prudence framework: performance, fees, liquidity, valuation, performance benchmarks, and complexity—making fiduciary judgments presumptively compliant with ERISA section 404(a)(1)(B).
- • The rule is asset-neutral and does not favor specific investment classes, instead emphasizing fiduciary process and discretion consistent with the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA), responding to President Trump's August 2025 Executive Order directing expanded alternative asset access.
- • Editorial boards and policy experts have praised the proposal for increasing choice and strengthening guardrails for retirement savers, citing potential for enhanced diversification and returns from private markets; however, Senator Warren and some financial advisors have expressed concerns about investor sophistication and exposure to higher-risk, higher-fee investments.
Summary
The Department of Labor released a proposed rule on April 10, 2026, titled "Fiduciary Duties in Selecting Designated Investment Alternatives," which would substantially broaden access to alternative investments within 401(k) plans. The proposal directly implements President Trump's August 2025 Executive Order on democratizing access to alternative assets for 401(k) investors and stands as the most comprehensive regulatory framework to date governing private market inclusion in defined-contribution retirement plans. According to the DOL, the rule could expand investment options for more than 90 million Americans currently holding 401(k) accounts.
The proposed regulation is fundamentally process-oriented rather than product-focused. Plan fiduciaries would be required to objectively, thoroughly, and analytically consider six specified factors when evaluating alternative investments: performance, fees, liquidity, valuation, performance benchmarks, and complexity. The rule establishes a regulatory safe harbor that presumes fiduciary compliance with ERISA's prudence standard under section 404(a)(1)(B) when fiduciaries follow the prescribed evaluation process. This safe harbor significantly reduces litigation exposure for plan sponsors and fiduciaries who incorporate alternatives, addressing a primary barrier to broader alternative asset adoption in retirement plans.
Industry experts and editorial boards have largely endorsed the proposal, emphasizing its alignment with ERISA's foundational principles of fiduciary discretion and process-based decision-making. Bonnie Treichel, ERISA attorney and CEO of Endeavor Retirement, noted that the rule grounds fiduciary obligations in prudent process rather than outcome, preserving maximum flexibility while establishing clear guardrails. Labor Secretary Lori Chavez-DeRemer stated the rule "will show how plans can consider products that better reflect the investment landscape as it exists today," while Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent characterized it as advancing the administration's "Golden Age" initiative by broadening retirement options while protecting retirement assets.
However, regulatory and advocacy concerns have surfaced. Senator Elizabeth Warren criticized the expansion, arguing it would "expose Americans' retirement accounts to private markets and cryptocurrencies" and citing recent issues in certain cryptocurrency and private market investments. Additionally, some financial advisors have raised questions about retail investor sophistication and whether many 401(k) participants possess adequate knowledge to evaluate complex, illiquid alternative investments with potentially higher fee structures and concentration risks.
The rule is currently in proposed form and subject to public comment, with the DOL and Treasury Department signaling commitment to collaborative implementation of the Executive Order's directive to modernize the retirement investment landscape.
The proposed regulation is fundamentally process-oriented rather than product-focused. Plan fiduciaries would be required to objectively, thoroughly, and analytically consider six specified factors when evaluating alternative investments: performance, fees, liquidity, valuation, performance benchmarks, and complexity. The rule establishes a regulatory safe harbor that presumes fiduciary compliance with ERISA's prudence standard under section 404(a)(1)(B) when fiduciaries follow the prescribed evaluation process. This safe harbor significantly reduces litigation exposure for plan sponsors and fiduciaries who incorporate alternatives, addressing a primary barrier to broader alternative asset adoption in retirement plans.
Industry experts and editorial boards have largely endorsed the proposal, emphasizing its alignment with ERISA's foundational principles of fiduciary discretion and process-based decision-making. Bonnie Treichel, ERISA attorney and CEO of Endeavor Retirement, noted that the rule grounds fiduciary obligations in prudent process rather than outcome, preserving maximum flexibility while establishing clear guardrails. Labor Secretary Lori Chavez-DeRemer stated the rule "will show how plans can consider products that better reflect the investment landscape as it exists today," while Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent characterized it as advancing the administration's "Golden Age" initiative by broadening retirement options while protecting retirement assets.
However, regulatory and advocacy concerns have surfaced. Senator Elizabeth Warren criticized the expansion, arguing it would "expose Americans' retirement accounts to private markets and cryptocurrencies" and citing recent issues in certain cryptocurrency and private market investments. Additionally, some financial advisors have raised questions about retail investor sophistication and whether many 401(k) participants possess adequate knowledge to evaluate complex, illiquid alternative investments with potentially higher fee structures and concentration risks.
The rule is currently in proposed form and subject to public comment, with the DOL and Treasury Department signaling commitment to collaborative implementation of the Executive Order's directive to modernize the retirement investment landscape.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.