Key Takeaways
- • Multiple large public pensions are reducing private equity allocations in 2025, including state retirement systems in Ohio, Maine, Nevada, Washington, Oregon, Texas, and Alaska, signaling institutional retreat from the asset class amid deteriorating performance.
- • Private equity assets under management fell for the first time in decades last year, with investors confronting a $3 trillion backlog of aging and unsold portfolio companies while pulling back from new capital commitments.
- • 5-year annualized private equity returns have declined materially from a 2021 peak, with analyst expectations forecasting performance will decline further toward approximately 6% by 2026, according to Callan and Cambridge Associates analysis.
- • The Alaska Permanent Fund ($85 billion AUM) is preparing to cut private equity allocation from 18% to 15%, with investment staff characterizing private equity's "golden era" as concluded and warning that sector growth has created a "$3 trillion backlog" of undeployed capital and illiquid zombie companies.
- • US public pensions allocate 14% to private equity on average, reflecting a 15-year shift toward alternative investments, but structural headwinds including liquidity constraints, high fees, and compressed exit opportunities are forcing strategic repositioning.
Summary
Large institutional investors are retreating from private equity allocations as the asset class faces a confluence of mounting headwinds: deteriorating returns, a historically unprecedented backlog of unsold portfolio companies, and constrained liquidity. According to the Financial Times reporting cited in industry analysis, private equity assets under management declined last year for the first time in decades as investor appetite for new commitments contracted. Multiple state pension systems have made allocation cuts during 2025, including Ohio, Maine, Nevada, Washington, Oregon, Texas, and Alaska, reflecting a coordinated institutional reassessment of the sector's risk-return profile.
The performance deterioration has been material and directional. Private equity achieved peak 5-year annualized returns in 2021, but subsequent returns have declined markedly. Using analysis from Callan and Cambridge Associates, performance expectations are projected to decline further, trending toward approximately 6% annually by 2026. This compression stands in sharp contrast to the equity markets' outperformance and reflects both cyclical and structural challenges within the private equity ecosystem.
The Alaska Permanent Fund Corporation (APFC), managing $85 billion in assets, exemplifies the institutional pivot underway. The fund's investment staff have recommended reducing private equity allocation from the current 18% to 15% for board consideration in early 2026. Notably, APFC staff have characterized private equity's period of superior returns as concluded, stating the sector's "golden era" is in the rearview mirror. This assessment reflects recognition that the rapid capital inflows into private equity over the past 15 years, combined with weak exit conditions and stalled portfolio company liquidity events, have created structural impediments to generating returns comparable to historical benchmarks.
The sector is burdened with significant structural challenges. Industry data indicates a $3 trillion backlog of aging and unsold deals remains deployed in private equity funds, creating a liquidity crunch as investors face extended holding periods and reduced exit optionality. Additionally, dry powder (undeployed committed capital) has accumulated, with APFC staff ironically noting that "there is no investment idea so good that it cannot be ruined by too much capital." US public pensions allocate 14% to private equity on average, reflecting a deliberate shift toward alternatives over the past 15 years, but the combination of illiquidity, elevated fee structures, and compressed returns is prompting large allocators to right-size their exposure to the asset class.
The performance deterioration has been material and directional. Private equity achieved peak 5-year annualized returns in 2021, but subsequent returns have declined markedly. Using analysis from Callan and Cambridge Associates, performance expectations are projected to decline further, trending toward approximately 6% annually by 2026. This compression stands in sharp contrast to the equity markets' outperformance and reflects both cyclical and structural challenges within the private equity ecosystem.
The Alaska Permanent Fund Corporation (APFC), managing $85 billion in assets, exemplifies the institutional pivot underway. The fund's investment staff have recommended reducing private equity allocation from the current 18% to 15% for board consideration in early 2026. Notably, APFC staff have characterized private equity's period of superior returns as concluded, stating the sector's "golden era" is in the rearview mirror. This assessment reflects recognition that the rapid capital inflows into private equity over the past 15 years, combined with weak exit conditions and stalled portfolio company liquidity events, have created structural impediments to generating returns comparable to historical benchmarks.
The sector is burdened with significant structural challenges. Industry data indicates a $3 trillion backlog of aging and unsold deals remains deployed in private equity funds, creating a liquidity crunch as investors face extended holding periods and reduced exit optionality. Additionally, dry powder (undeployed committed capital) has accumulated, with APFC staff ironically noting that "there is no investment idea so good that it cannot be ruined by too much capital." US public pensions allocate 14% to private equity on average, reflecting a deliberate shift toward alternatives over the past 15 years, but the combination of illiquidity, elevated fee structures, and compressed returns is prompting large allocators to right-size their exposure to the asset class.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.