Key Takeaways
- • Colby College's $1.2 billion endowment delivered an 11.7% return for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2025, outperforming the median university endowment return of 11.2% for the same period.
- • Venture capital allocations were a material performance driver for Colby's results, contributing to returns that exceeded peer benchmarks during a strong year for alternative assets.
- • Colby's endowment spending supports over 20% of the college's annual operating budget, including financial aid, faculty and staff compensation, making investment performance directly material to institutional operations.
- • FY2025 marked the second consecutive year of double-digit returns for large endowments, with institutions managing $1 billion or more averaging 11.5% returns against a 12.7% policy benchmark (65% MSCI ACWI / 35% Bloomberg Aggregate).
Summary
Colby College's endowment generated an 11.7% return for fiscal year 2025 (ended June 30), driven in part by allocations to venture capital during a period of broad strength across higher education investment portfolios. The $1.2 billion endowment's performance tracked above the median return of 11.2% reported across U.S. higher education institutions, according to data from the 2025 NACUBO-Commonfund Study of Endowments.
The college's allocation to venture capital proved particularly advantageous during the fiscal year, capitalizing on improved exit environments and valuations in private markets. This tactical positioning reflects the broader trend across large endowments, where alternative assets—particularly private equity and venture capital—have become essential return drivers. FY2025 represented the second consecutive year of double-digit returns for the largest endowments, with institutions managing $1 billion or more averaging 11.5% returns.
For Colby specifically, endowment performance carries direct operational relevance: spending distributions from the endowment currently fund more than 20% of the college's annual budget, supporting financial aid, faculty and staff salaries, and other institutional priorities. This structural dependence underscores the materiality of investment returns to the college's ability to maintain its competitive positioning in faculty recruitment and student affordability.
Broader context shows the higher education endowment complex stabilized after navigating prior-year headwinds related to valuation pressures and liquidity constraints. The 10-year average return across all participating institutions stood at 7.7% for fiscal 2025, reflecting normalized performance relative to the exceptional returns of the 2021-2022 period. Colby's peer cohort—large institutions with substantial alternative allocations—continues to benefit from the structural shift toward illiquid, higher-yielding asset classes that characterized endowment strategy evolution over the past decade.
The college's allocation to venture capital proved particularly advantageous during the fiscal year, capitalizing on improved exit environments and valuations in private markets. This tactical positioning reflects the broader trend across large endowments, where alternative assets—particularly private equity and venture capital—have become essential return drivers. FY2025 represented the second consecutive year of double-digit returns for the largest endowments, with institutions managing $1 billion or more averaging 11.5% returns.
For Colby specifically, endowment performance carries direct operational relevance: spending distributions from the endowment currently fund more than 20% of the college's annual budget, supporting financial aid, faculty and staff salaries, and other institutional priorities. This structural dependence underscores the materiality of investment returns to the college's ability to maintain its competitive positioning in faculty recruitment and student affordability.
Broader context shows the higher education endowment complex stabilized after navigating prior-year headwinds related to valuation pressures and liquidity constraints. The 10-year average return across all participating institutions stood at 7.7% for fiscal 2025, reflecting normalized performance relative to the exceptional returns of the 2021-2022 period. Colby's peer cohort—large institutions with substantial alternative allocations—continues to benefit from the structural shift toward illiquid, higher-yielding asset classes that characterized endowment strategy evolution over the past decade.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.