Key Takeaways
- • Harvard Management Company executives, led by CEO N.P. "Narv" Narvekar and investment chief Rick Slocum, toured Silicon Valley in January 2024 to repair relations with venture-capital managers upset over the university's response to the Oct. 7 attacks on Israel.
- • The endowment, valued at $51 billion, met with Sequoia Capital, Kleiner Perkins, Andreessen Horowitz, Elad Gil and Stripe CEO Patrick Collison, per the Wall Street Journal report; Harvard is a direct investor in Stripe.
- • Endowment chair Paul Finnegan, a member of the 12-person Harvard Corporation, joined some manager meetings, an unusual step according to the report.
- • The pressure came from venture managers rather than from the big donors who led the broader uproar, and it highlights the importance of venture exposure to Harvard's returns.
- • Harvard's endowment averaged 8.2% annually over the 10 fiscal years ended June 30 and 9.1% over five years, the second-worst records in the Ivy League for both periods.
Summary
The endowment met with firms including Sequoia Capital, Kleiner Perkins and Andreessen Horowitz, as well as Elad Gil and Patrick Collison, chief executive of payments company Stripe. Both are influential in Silicon Valley and have been among the more outspoken voices toward Harvard's endowment. Private-equity executive Paul Finnegan, the endowment's chair and a member of the Harvard Corporation, also attended some meetings. Endowment spokesman Patrick McKiernan said in a statement that the firm has longstanding relationships with managers who care about higher education and that it was engaging partners on the university's efforts to ensure student safety and protect free speech.
According to people familiar with the tour, it was driven less by fear of losing allocations than by a desire to partner with managers and answer questions. Executives also addressed criticism that Gay's initial statement on the Hamas attacks was too weak. Finnegan said Gay had sought input from school deans, a process that weakened the statement, and he acknowledged criticism that diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives had gone too far. Harvard was considering whether changes were needed to protect academic freedom, he said. Executives also said the endowment is not political and plays no role in selecting the president.
The venture relationship matters to Harvard's returns. The endowment has long lagged peers in venture exposure, and under Narvekar, who joined from Columbia in late 2016, it has increased that exposure and wants to increase it further, though demand for spots in top funds regularly exceeds availability. Narvekar, hired to turn around the endowment, has shuttered most internal trading, written down $1 billion in timber and natural resources investments, and outsourced money management to external managers.
The Wall Street Journal reported that Slocum has also been in contact with Josh Kushner of Thrive Capital, an outspoken venture manager on Israel and antisemitism and the brother of Jared Kushner.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.