Key Takeaways
- • Yale's endowment defended high private equity and alternative asset fees in its 2017 annual report, citing 20-year leveraged buyout returns of 12.6 percent annually and venture capital returns of 25.5 percent (time-weighted), substantially outperforming public markets.
- • The endowment's overall 20-year return of 12.1 percent exceeded the Wilshire 5000 stock index return of 7.5 percent, demonstrating the performance justification for Yale's alternative-heavy allocation strategy.
- • Yale targets a long-term allocation of approximately 50 percent of its investment portfolio to alternatives including leveraged buyouts, venture capital, real estate, and natural resources—a gradual 30-year strategic shift now substantially in place.
- • The endowment directly addressed Warren Buffett's critique of high alternative asset fees, arguing that net returns—not gross fees—determine investment merit, and that top-performing managers have overcome fee burdens to deliver extraordinary results.
- • Yale's investment committee modestly reduced its target allocation to leveraged buyouts from 15 percent to 14 percent in 2017, while maintaining conviction in the broader private equity and alternatives thesis.
Summary
Yale University's endowment published its 2017 annual report with a forceful defense of its substantial allocation to private equity, venture capital, and other alternative assets—directly rebutting criticism regarding the high fee structures embedded in these investments. The endowment argued that net returns, rather than gross fees, constitute the appropriate metric for evaluating investment performance and that skilled managers in the alternatives space have consistently overcome fee burdens to deliver superior risk-adjusted returns.
The performance data underpinning Yale's argument is material. Over a 20-year period, the endowment's leveraged buyout portfolio generated 12.6 percent annual returns, while its venture capital portfolio achieved 25.5 percent annualized returns on a time-weighted basis. The report acknowledged that venture capital's exceptional returns were partially driven by significant gains during the Internet bubble period, providing transparency around return composition. The endowment's overall 20-year return of 12.1 percent substantially exceeded the Wilshire 5000 stock index return of 7.5 percent, demonstrating the empirical case for Yale's diversified alternatives strategy.
Yale's strategic positioning reflects a deliberate, multi-decade shift toward alternatives. The endowment intends to allocate approximately 50 percent of its investment portfolio to leveraged buyouts, venture capital, real estate, and natural resources over the long term. This allocation reflects the institution's conviction that alternatives provide both portfolio diversification benefits and opportunities for skilled active managers to generate alpha. However, the endowment demonstrated tactical flexibility in 2017 by reducing its target allocation to leveraged buyouts from 15 percent to 14 percent, indicating ongoing portfolio optimization despite broader commitment to the alternatives thesis.
The report explicitly addressed Warren Buffett's well-publicized reservations about alternative asset fees, positioning Yale's experience as evidence that top-tier managers in private equity and venture capital have successfully delivered returns net of their cost structure. This defense of Yale's allocation framework carries particular weight given the endowment's reputation as a historically superior long-term performer and its status as a model emulated by institutional investors across the higher education and foundation sectors.
The performance data underpinning Yale's argument is material. Over a 20-year period, the endowment's leveraged buyout portfolio generated 12.6 percent annual returns, while its venture capital portfolio achieved 25.5 percent annualized returns on a time-weighted basis. The report acknowledged that venture capital's exceptional returns were partially driven by significant gains during the Internet bubble period, providing transparency around return composition. The endowment's overall 20-year return of 12.1 percent substantially exceeded the Wilshire 5000 stock index return of 7.5 percent, demonstrating the empirical case for Yale's diversified alternatives strategy.
Yale's strategic positioning reflects a deliberate, multi-decade shift toward alternatives. The endowment intends to allocate approximately 50 percent of its investment portfolio to leveraged buyouts, venture capital, real estate, and natural resources over the long term. This allocation reflects the institution's conviction that alternatives provide both portfolio diversification benefits and opportunities for skilled active managers to generate alpha. However, the endowment demonstrated tactical flexibility in 2017 by reducing its target allocation to leveraged buyouts from 15 percent to 14 percent, indicating ongoing portfolio optimization despite broader commitment to the alternatives thesis.
The report explicitly addressed Warren Buffett's well-publicized reservations about alternative asset fees, positioning Yale's experience as evidence that top-tier managers in private equity and venture capital have successfully delivered returns net of their cost structure. This defense of Yale's allocation framework carries particular weight given the endowment's reputation as a historically superior long-term performer and its status as a model emulated by institutional investors across the higher education and foundation sectors.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.