Key Takeaways
- • Recreatie, a Dutch hospitality and recreation sector pension fund managing about £1.1bn (approximately €1.3bn) in assets, has appointed Cardano to replace BlackRock as manager of its €426m equity portfolio.
- • The switch was driven by a combination of cost-efficiency measures and ESG concerns, according to Dutch trade title Pensioen Pro.
- • AF Advisors scored a range of managers on 12 criteria, including costs and ESG considerations, with Cardano ranking strongest.
- • BlackRock acknowledged the decision, saying it respected the fund's choice and remains proud to manage more than €350bn for Dutch clients.
- • The move follows a wider pattern of asset owners reviewing mandates with large US managers after their climate-stance pullbacks from net zero and CA100+ coalitions.
Summary
Recreatie, which manages about £1.1bn for employees in the Dutch hospitality and recreation industry, has appointed Cardano as the new manager of its €426m equity portfolio, ending BlackRock's mandate, according to Net Zero Investor. The decision was taken due to a combination of cost efficiency measures and ESG concerns, according to Dutch trade title Pensioen Pro. The fund had engaged AF Advisors to score a range of managers on 12 criteria covering costs as well as ESG considerations, and Cardano ultimately came out strongest.
A BlackRock spokesperson acknowledged the move, stating that the manager respected the fund's decision and remained proud to manage more than €350bn on behalf of Dutch clients. The termination comes as BlackRock and other large US managers have withdrawn from the Net Zero Asset Managers Initiative and CA100+ over the past two years amid sustained pushback on their climate stance in the US, although BlackRock continues to offer climate-tilted funds to asset owners. Several other Dutch and UK asset owners, including PME, PFZW, People's Pension and Akademiker, have recently terminated mandates with large US managers citing climate stewardship concerns.
Recreatie has invested about €426m in equities and €677.7m in fixed income and liability hedging assets, with Cardano and BlackRock previously acting as its managers, according to its latest reports and accounts. The fund did not disclose whether the allocations are held in segregated mandates or pooled funds, though a €400m mandate would be relatively small in the Dutch institutional market, limiting options to customise climate and stewardship requirements. The decision follows the board's move two years ago to tighten its responsible investment stance toward SFDR Article 8 status, a common step among the Netherlands' largest pension funds.
The change also coincides with the Dutch shift from defined benefit to collective defined contribution (CDC) schemes. While the pensions reform is not directly linked to the manager change, Recreatie expects to increase its equity allocation as it transitions to CDC. Its 2025 results were weaker: the liability-matching portfolio returned -34%, bringing total investment returns to -8.5% despite strong equity markets, although the fund still reports a funding level above 131% due to currently high interest rates.
A BlackRock spokesperson acknowledged the move, stating that the manager respected the fund's decision and remained proud to manage more than €350bn on behalf of Dutch clients. The termination comes as BlackRock and other large US managers have withdrawn from the Net Zero Asset Managers Initiative and CA100+ over the past two years amid sustained pushback on their climate stance in the US, although BlackRock continues to offer climate-tilted funds to asset owners. Several other Dutch and UK asset owners, including PME, PFZW, People's Pension and Akademiker, have recently terminated mandates with large US managers citing climate stewardship concerns.
Recreatie has invested about €426m in equities and €677.7m in fixed income and liability hedging assets, with Cardano and BlackRock previously acting as its managers, according to its latest reports and accounts. The fund did not disclose whether the allocations are held in segregated mandates or pooled funds, though a €400m mandate would be relatively small in the Dutch institutional market, limiting options to customise climate and stewardship requirements. The decision follows the board's move two years ago to tighten its responsible investment stance toward SFDR Article 8 status, a common step among the Netherlands' largest pension funds.
The change also coincides with the Dutch shift from defined benefit to collective defined contribution (CDC) schemes. While the pensions reform is not directly linked to the manager change, Recreatie expects to increase its equity allocation as it transitions to CDC. Its 2025 results were weaker: the liability-matching portfolio returned -34%, bringing total investment returns to -8.5% despite strong equity markets, although the fund still reports a funding level above 131% due to currently high interest rates.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.