Key Takeaways
- • The Carlyle Group has decided not to pursue an acquisition of IGIS Asset Management Co., South Korea's largest real estate asset manager, after concluding the valuation sought was difficult to justify, according to people familiar with the matter.
- • The decision removes one of the foreign bidders from a sale process that has already seen Hillhouse named preferred buyer at a reported $750 million, with Hanwha Life and Heungkuk Life as domestic contenders.
- • The sale process has been destabilized by withdrawal of National Pension Service mandates and a police complaint filed by Heungkuk Life over the sale process.
- • The IGIS situation is a significant test of valuation discipline for large private market buyers in Korean real estate asset management.
Summary
The Carlyle decision comes amid a prolonged and contentious sale process. Singapore-headquartered Hillhouse Investment Management had previously been named the preferred buyer of IGIS in a deal valued at $750 million, after emerging as a late-stage bidder with a $682 million offer. The sale had been narrowed to a two-way contest between domestic insurers Hanwha Life Insurance Co. and Heungkuk Life Insurance Co.
The process has also faced significant turbulence. The National Pension Service, South Korea's state-run pension fund and Korea's top institutional investor, has moved to withdraw all of its money committed to IGIS and is pressing ahead with transferring several billion dollars in real estate mandates away from the firm. Heungkuk Life Insurance has filed a complaint with police against senior figures involved in the planned sale. Separately, the NPS and Shinsegae Property, anchor investors in the Centerfield office complex in Seoul, have pushed back against IGIS's plan to sell the property.
The IGIS controlling stake, owned by the heirs of the company's late founder and some major stakeholders, has been offered for sale. Carlyle's withdrawal underscores the gap between seller price expectations and buyer valuation discipline in the process.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.