Key Takeaways
- • Eswatini's Public Service Pension Fund (PSPF) has set aside the investment consultancy contract awarded to Cape Town firm Riscura after an Independent Review Committee under the Eswatini Public Procurement Regulatory Agency (ESSPRA) found the re-tender process flawed.
- • The PSPF, with assets under management of more than R22bn, had re-invited bidders in November 2021 even though Riscura had not been shortlisted in the initial 2020 tender.
- • Riscura ranked third overall on a weighted score of 63.9%, behind EEBC/Alexforbes (85.5%) and Orange (70.9%), though it led the technical assessment with 82.7%.
- • The review body ordered the PSPF to restart procurement with clear evaluation criteria, and found no wrongdoing on Riscura's part.
- • Riscura said it respected the ruling and noted that it had not been formally appointed, so it was not involved in the review.
Summary
The tender has a complicated history. The PSPF first invited bids in 2020, when Riscura did not participate and the investment committee recommended the Orange consortium. Before Orange could be appointed, an anonymous whistle-blower lodged misconduct allegations with South Africa's Financial Sector Conduct Authority, and the award was held in abeyance. Orange was subsequently cleared, but the PSPF cancelled the award because the investigation had taken too long.
In November 2021 the PSPF issued a new invitation to tender. Bidders were scored 70% on technical criteria and the balance on financial criteria. EEBC, partnering with Alexforbes, ranked first with a weighted score of 85.5%, followed by Orange at 70.9% and Riscura at 63.9%. Riscura nonetheless led on the technical assessment with 82.7%, and the investment committee recommended it. The PSPF board adopted that recommendation and resolved to appoint Riscura for three years to advise on its foreign and domestic portfolios.
EEBC challenged the decision, arguing that allowing Riscura to re-enter after all parties had disclosed pricing gave it an unfair advantage. The Independent Review Committee agreed that re-inviting the 2020 bidders was flawed, because the original tender had been cancelled rather than suspended. The ruling said Riscura had lacked the Financial Services Regulatory Authority licence or certificate required at the preliminary stage, and that the 2021 invitation should not have included it. The panel ordered the PSPF to restart procurement with clear evaluation criteria, and it attributed no wrongdoing to Riscura. A source close to the process alleged that Orange had been deliberately sabotaged after winning the initial contract, though this claim is unverified.
Riscura said it respected the decision of the review committee and noted that it had not been formally appointed. Spokesperson Bernadette Marais said the firm had not been involved in the ESSPRA review and could not comment on its substance.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.