Key Takeaways
- • Ortec Finance projects pension returns could fall by 10% to 30% by 2050 relative to current expectations under its Limited Action scenario, which models 2.8C of warming by 2100.
- • The analysis covers 180 pension fund portfolios across six major pension systems in the UK, US, Canada, Australia, the Netherlands and Switzerland.
- • Under a High Warming scenario of 3.8C by 2100, sovereign bond values could fall roughly 53% in India, 18% in China, 17% in the US and 5% in the UK, with global GDP about $58trn smaller by 2065.
- • Ortec managing director Maurits van Joolingen states that the climate outcome many scientists consider plausible is not a tail-risk scenario and could materially affect sovereign debt, insurance systems and pension returns.
Summary
Ortec managing director Maurits van Joolingen said the climate future many scientists now consider plausible "is not a tail-risk scenario," and could have material consequences for sovereign debt markets, insurance systems and, ultimately, pension fund returns. He added that investors must understand how these risks interact and vary across regions while keeping portfolios resilient as physical climate risks grow in importance relative to traditional financial risks.
The report also examines sovereign credit risk, which it says would intensify as warming worsens, particularly for highly indebted countries. Under the High Warming scenario, which projects 3.8C by 2100, sovereign bond values would fall by about 53% in India, 18% in China, 17% in the US and 5% in the UK. Cumulative GDP growth would fall to 32%, leaving the global economy at around $156trn by 2065, roughly $58trn below its current growth trajectory and close to half the economy's current size. Under the Limited Action scenario, estimated valuation declines are 23% in India, 4% in China, and 1% each in the US and UK.
The article notes a gap between investor preferences and current allocations. A YouGov survey cited in the report found most British residents want their pension savings invested in renewable energy, including around half of Reform UK voters. Despite this, many schemes continue to back fossil fuel expanders, including a majority of funds in OECD countries. While three-quarters of UK pension funds have net-zero targets, current strategies still fall short of the Paris Agreement's 2C limit, according to the report.
Separate research from CRIF, released the previous week, found 57% of UK business decision-makers are more likely to choose a financial provider with strong ESG practices. However, 63% said price should take priority over sustainability, and 56% said providers should prioritise supporting growth over ESG progress.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.