Key Takeaways
- • Montreal law firm Trudel Johnston & Lespérance (TJL), acting for Stand.earth, sent letters to six large Canadian pension plans warning that LNG investments may breach fiduciary duty; no lawsuit has been filed yet.
- • The six recipients manage more than $1.6 trillion in assets: CPPIB, PSP, OMERS, OTPP, UPP and HOOPP.
- • The letters cite an expected global LNG glut by 2028 that could push prices to US$5-8 per MMBtu, below LNG Canada's estimated break-even of US$10-15, plus cost overruns on projects such as Coastal GasLink and Woodfibre LNG.
- • CPPIB and three other pension funds joined Blackstone in a $4.3 billion deal for a 49.9% stake in the Mitsubishi subsidiary holding LNG Canada's interest, a transaction that prompted the legal challenge.
- • Ottawa targets raising Canada's LNG export capacity from under 14 million tonnes a year to 100 million by 2040, a goal analysts say faces significant risks.
Summary
The letters argue that deeper investment in Canadian LNG is financially perilous in a volatile market facing a global gas glut. They cite International Energy Agency forecasts of an LNG glut by 2028 that could push prices to US$5-8 per million British thermal units, compared with LNG Canada's estimated break-even of US$10-15. They also point to systemic cost overruns: the Coastal GasLink pipeline's price rose from C$4 billion to C$14.5 billion, and the unbuilt Woodfibre LNG project has climbed to US$8.8 billion from an initial US$5.1 billion. Rapid renewables growth could further erode demand in the Asian and European markets Ottawa is targeting. TJL partner Anne-Julie Asselin said the financial risks of the shift away from oil and gas are "significant, foreseeable and increasing."
The letters reference the $30 billion Ksi Lisims LNG facility in northwest British Columbia and LNG Canada's $33 billion Phase 2 expansion at Kitimat. The challenge follows the Nov. 2 deal in which CPPIB and three other large pension funds joined US private equity firm Blackstone in a $4.3 billion transaction for a 49.9% stake in the Mitsubishi Corp. subsidiary that holds the Japanese firm's interest in LNG Canada. CPPIB's Geoffrey Souter, head of real assets credit, described LNG Canada as "a high-quality, globally strategic asset with strong long-term fundamentals and attractive return potential." Prime Minister Mark Carney said the expansion "will connect low-cost, low-carbon Canadian energy to global markets."
The federal Liberal government aims to lift Canada's LNG export capacity from under 14 million tonnes a year to 100 million by 2040. Historically, the so-called Maple 8 pension managers have avoided domestic LNG projects over concerns about cost overruns, execution risk and price swings, though critics say federal promotion has changed that. Finance Minister François-Philippe Champagne told CNO that pension funds are "very interested in Canada" as they seek portfolio diversification. Canada is also pitching itself as a reliable supplier to Europe as the Iran war and Strait of Hormuz disruptions reshape global energy flows, and Carney has agreed to explore a long-term LNG deal with the European Union.
Analysts have raised doubts. Seb Kennedy, an independent gas and LNG analyst, said in an Oct. 23 report titled "Canadian LNG: the maple-leafed mirage" that shipping cargoes from BC to Japan instead of Rotterdam earns an offtaker US$15.2 million more per cargo at current prices, and about US$10 million more at 2032 prices. Mark Kalegha of the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis said that while favourable markets could produce cash flows matching pension requirements, less optimistic scenarios would leave funds holding stranded assets, which he called "a very unfavourable outcome" for pensioners. He also noted that CPPIB's decision last year to abandon its net-zero-by-2050 portfolio pledge reflected "acute governance risks surrounding these investments." Separately, four young Canada Pension Plan contributors are asking an Ontario court to clarify the investment board's duty on climate risk.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.