Key Takeaways
- • The National Pension Fund returned 18.82% in 2025, 2.9 times the 6.47% average for South Korea's corporate retirement plans, according to the Ministry of Employment and Labor.
- • Excluding principal-guaranteed products such as bank deposits (which returned 3.09%), performance-based retirement plan products returned 16.80%, narrowing the gap to about 2.02 percentage points from 12.35 points.
- • Performance-based DC plan products returned 19.82% in 2025, 1 percentage point ahead of the National Pension Fund, but fell 16.92% in 2022 versus the fund's 8.22% decline.
- • National Pension Service chairman Kim Sung-joo said in June that the agency could deliver more than three times current returns and cut fees to about a third of current levels if given fund-type retirement plans to manage.
- • Critics argue the National Pension Fund's long-term, equity-heavy strategy cannot transfer to retirement plans, which must meet job-change transfers and severance payouts.
Summary
The National Pension Service has cited the fund's results as grounds for taking on management of fund-type retirement plans. Chairman Kim Sung-joo told a press briefing in June that the agency could deliver more than three times current returns and reduce fees to about a third of present levels under that arrangement. Critics counter that a single year's results are a weak guide, since rankings reverse with market conditions. Performance-based DC plan products returned 19.82% in 2025, one point ahead of the National Pension Fund, but in 2022 they fell 16.92%, 8.70 percentage points more than the fund's 8.22% decline.
An industry official attributed the National Pension Fund's results to steady inflows that allow it to ride out volatility while keeping a high equity allocation. Retirement plans, by contrast, must pay out accrued savings when workers switch employers and pay severance, so the agency could not hold equities at the same weight even if it managed them, the official said.
The fund-type plan Blue Seed, for small and midsize firm employees, illustrates the constraint. At year-end, it held 23.1% of assets in domestic and overseas equities and 76.9% in bonds and short-term instruments. It returned 6.97% in 2023, 6.52% in 2024 and 8.67% in 2025, beating the overall retirement plan average by 1.7 to 2.2 points annually but trailing performance-based products by 3.4 to 8.1 points. Analysts say the National Pension Fund's past results are therefore a poor benchmark for returns under the agency's management.
The government is pushing to introduce fund-type retirement plans, but whether the National Pension Service participates, and at what scale, will be decided through parliamentary deliberations. The agency already outsources part of the National Pension Fund to private asset managers and would compete with them for retirement plan mandates. One industry official said asset managers "will have no choice but to tread carefully" if the agency enters the business.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.