Key Takeaways
- • The United Federation of Teachers filed a notice of claim with the city comptroller's office against the Teachers Retirement System (TRS) on a Tuesday, the required prerequisite before suing the city for damages over a pension clawback affecting 183 disabled retired paraprofessionals.
- • TRS acknowledged in letters to retirees that the overpayments, which by some estimates cost the pension fund about $155,000 a month, resulted from its own calculation error, and it announced that the retirees should receive one-third rather than two-thirds of their final average salaries.
- • UFT president Michael Mulgrew disclosed the filing at a delegates assembly meeting, saying negotiations with TRS had not produced a timely resolution, and the union argues TRS has discretion to protect those least able to afford financial harm.
- • TRS and Mayor Zohran Mamdani maintain the city has a legal obligation to recover the overpayments, while TRS had agreed to pause clawbacks until January.
- • The TRS board of trustees, which includes Comptroller Mark Levine, was scheduled to meet Thursday, and the Law Department said the notice of claim is under review.
Summary
The dispute dates to mid-June, when more than 180 retired paraprofessionals were informed by TRS that their monthly payments would be reduced by as much as half, with amounts recouped from future checks to offset more than 20 years of overpayments. In those letters, TRS acknowledged that the error was the pension system's, not the retirees'. The retirees had been receiving pensions equal to two-thirds of their final average salaries, whereas under state law, retirees eligible for Workers' Compensation are owed one-third. Some estimates put the overpayments at about $155,000 a month. TRS had agreed to pause clawbacks until January while the union negotiated a resolution.
TRS and Mayor Zohran Mamdani have said the city has a legal obligation to recover the overpayments. Mamdani said in August that the Law Department had identified the matter as a mistake spanning many years requiring legal compliance. The UFT and retiree advocates argue that the recovery efforts are cruel and that the retirees should keep their pensions because the error originated with the fund. In its notice of claim, the UFT contends that under TRS's governing laws the fund has "discretion to ensure that those least able to afford it are not subject to financial harm due to TRS's own mistakes." Law Department spokesperson Nicholas Paolucci said the notice of claim is "under review," and City Hall said the administration had no further comment.
The TRS board of trustees, which includes city Comptroller Mark Levine, three teacher members, a representative of the Panel for Educational Policy, and a mayoral appointee, was scheduled to meet Thursday afternoon. Levine has not publicly stated his position and has referred questions to TRS. The affected retirees all left their jobs early due to on-the-job injuries, including assaults by students, and several have described severe financial strain, with some dropping doctors and prescriptions.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.