Key Takeaways
- • The Court of Appeals upheld a 5,100 hryvnia fine against the Pension Fund of Ukraine for failing to pay a one-time 1,000,000 hryvnia benefit owed to the husband of a deceased Chornomorsk Port employee.
- • The Fifth Administrative Court of Appeals ruling, dated November 12, 2026, rejected the Pension Fund's claims of a funding shortfall and software limitations as unconvincing.
- • The court found the Pension Fund had calculated the benefit but never paid it, and it provided insufficient evidence that technical or funding constraints prevented compliance.
- • The ruling has taken legal effect, leaving the underlying court order to pay the benefit in force.
Summary
The benefit is provided under Ukrainian law to employees of critical infrastructure facilities who have suffered as a result of Russian military aggression, as well as to their families. In 2025, the Odesa District Administrative Court ordered the Main Directorate of the Pension Fund in the Odesa region to grant and pay the assistance to the widower. The decision was issued in July 2025 and upheld by the appellate court in September of that year.
The Pension Fund did not fully comply with the ruling. The agency said it could not complete the calculation and payment due to technical limitations in its software, cited a lack of necessary funding, and reported that it had entered information about the debt into the relevant registry. In July 2026, a state enforcement officer fined the fund 5,100 hryvnias for non-compliance. The agency appealed the fine, but the court of first instance denied the appeal.
The Court of Appeals upheld that decision. The panel found that the fund had calculated the benefits but had not paid them, and that it had not provided sufficient evidence that technical issues or a lack of funds objectively prevented compliance. The fund's appeal was dismissed, and the fine is now final.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.