Key Takeaways
- • CalPERS voted on November 16 to retain its existing divestment mandates on tobacco, firearms, Iran, and thermal coal, despite staff analysis estimating those restrictions cost the fund $6.4 billion in investment returns since implementation.
- • The five-year review estimated a collective $1.5 billion in lost returns since the last review in 2021, on a pension fund of roughly $651.3 billion.
- • Tobacco was the largest drag, with a $942 million negative impact over the last five years and a $7 billion cumulative loss since the 2001 divestment; Iran cost $627 million over the period.
- • Firearms and thermal coal restrictions produced positive returns of $25 million and $70 million, respectively, over the five-year period.
- • Wilshire, CalPERS' general investment consultant, found no financial basis to change course, stating the financial evidence 'does not compel a directional change.'
Summary
The divestments limit CalPERS' holdings across its private and public equities portfolios. In some cases the restrictions completely prohibit holdings in select companies, such as primary tobacco producers and manufacturers of assault-style weapons illegal for sale in California. CalPERS first voted to divest from tobacco in 2001 and firearms in 2013. The Iran and thermal coal divestments were required by legislation passed in 2011 and 2017, respectively. The pension system also once divested from Sudan but reversed that decision in 2020 after the U.S. lifted sanctions on Sudan and removed it from the list of state sponsors of terrorism.
Tobacco accounted for the largest share of the reported losses, with a $942 million negative impact on returns over the latest five-year period and a $7 billion loss since the 2001 divestment. Iran followed with a $627 million negative return over the same period. Firearms and thermal coal restrictions were associated with positive returns of $25 million and $70 million, respectively. As of June 30, 2026, the divested securities represented roughly 62 basis points of the public equity benchmark, or $1.5 billion of a $242 billion portfolio, with tobacco making up $1.35 billion of that exposure and firearms having zero benchmark exposure.
Michelle Louie, an investment manager at CalPERS, presented predicted tracking error, which she described as a forward-looking estimate of how much a portfolio excluding the divestment securities could differ from one that includes them. She cautioned that it does not indicate which portfolio will perform better. Together, the four mandates generated 14 basis points of predicted tracking error relative to the unrestricted portfolio.
Wilshire, CalPERS' general investment consultant, reviewed the staff analysis and found no financial basis to deviate from the current approach. Lauren Gellhaus, vice president of institutional investments at Wilshire, said the staff analysis is 'thorough, appropriately framed, and supported by reasonable estimates,' and that 'affirmation is a reasonable outcome,' with any future change to be evaluated program by program.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.