Key Takeaways
- • President Trump issued an executive order on August 7, 2025, directing the Department of Labor to re-evaluate ERISA guidance on alternative assets in defined contribution plans by February 3, 2026, with the stated goal of expanding participant access to private equity, digital currencies, real estate, commodities, infrastructure, and lifetime income strategies.
- • The order explicitly targets litigation risk reduction, instructing DOL to prioritize actions that deter private plaintiffs from bringing ERISA lawsuits against fiduciaries offering alternative investments—signaling a regulatory shift favorable to DC plan sponsors considering alternatives exposure.
- • Alternative assets covered by the order span private market investments (private equity, private credit), digital assets (cryptocurrencies), real estate, commodities, infrastructure development, and longevity risk-sharing pools, with fiduciaries authorized to offer them when they determine they enhance net risk-adjusted returns for participants.
- • The $12.5 trillion in defined contribution plan assets represents a significant target for alternative asset managers, as defined benefit plans have long held larger allocations to alternatives while DC plans have lagged due to perceived regulatory and litigation barriers.
- • No immediate action is required of DC plan sponsors or fiduciaries pending DOL's guidance clarification, but the order signals a substantial policy shift that will likely reshape investment options available in 401(k) plans and other DC arrangements.
Summary
On August 7, 2025, President Trump issued an executive order titled "Democratizing Access to Alternative Assets for 401(k) Investors," charging the Department of Labor with re-evaluating existing ERISA guidance on alternative asset allocation in defined contribution plans. The DOL has until February 3, 2026, to clarify its position on participant access to these investments and to take action aimed at reducing litigation risk for fiduciaries who offer them. The order represents a significant policy shift intended to encourage DC plan fiduciaries to expand exposure to investment categories historically reserved for defined benefit plans and institutional investors.
The executive order covers a broad spectrum of alternative asset classes. These include private market investments holding equity, debt, or other financial instruments not traded on public exchanges—particularly private equity funds with active management involvement in portfolio companies—as well as actively managed vehicles investing in digital assets such as cryptocurrencies. Real estate, commodities, infrastructure development projects, and lifetime income investment strategies, including "longevity risk-sharing pools," are also included. The order stipulates that participants should have access to funds investing in these alternatives when plan fiduciaries determine they provide an appropriate opportunity to enhance net risk-adjusted returns on retirement assets.
The executive order explicitly acknowledges that many defined benefit plans already hold substantial allocations to alternative assets but identifies litigation risk and what the administration characterizes as "burdensome" DOL guidance as key deterrents preventing DC fiduciaries from offering similar opportunities. By instructing DOL to prioritize actions that will deter private plaintiffs from bringing ERISA lawsuits against fiduciaries, the order signals a fundamental regulatory recalibration designed to shield plan sponsors and fiduciaries from litigation exposure. This litigation-risk reduction framework is intended to create a more permissive environment for alternatives adoption.
The $12.5 trillion in assets held within DC plans represents substantial capital that alternative asset managers have long sought to access. The gap between alternatives adoption in defined benefit versus defined contribution arrangements has reflected regulatory uncertainty and fiduciary liability concerns rather than investment merit. With DOL guidance expected by early 2026, DC plan sponsors should monitor forthcoming clarifications closely, though no immediate action is required pending the agency's formal position. The order's emphasis on fiduciary discretion in determining risk-adjusted return enhancement suggests the final guidance will grant significant latitude to plan sponsors in structuring alternatives exposure for participants.
The executive order covers a broad spectrum of alternative asset classes. These include private market investments holding equity, debt, or other financial instruments not traded on public exchanges—particularly private equity funds with active management involvement in portfolio companies—as well as actively managed vehicles investing in digital assets such as cryptocurrencies. Real estate, commodities, infrastructure development projects, and lifetime income investment strategies, including "longevity risk-sharing pools," are also included. The order stipulates that participants should have access to funds investing in these alternatives when plan fiduciaries determine they provide an appropriate opportunity to enhance net risk-adjusted returns on retirement assets.
The executive order explicitly acknowledges that many defined benefit plans already hold substantial allocations to alternative assets but identifies litigation risk and what the administration characterizes as "burdensome" DOL guidance as key deterrents preventing DC fiduciaries from offering similar opportunities. By instructing DOL to prioritize actions that will deter private plaintiffs from bringing ERISA lawsuits against fiduciaries, the order signals a fundamental regulatory recalibration designed to shield plan sponsors and fiduciaries from litigation exposure. This litigation-risk reduction framework is intended to create a more permissive environment for alternatives adoption.
The $12.5 trillion in assets held within DC plans represents substantial capital that alternative asset managers have long sought to access. The gap between alternatives adoption in defined benefit versus defined contribution arrangements has reflected regulatory uncertainty and fiduciary liability concerns rather than investment merit. With DOL guidance expected by early 2026, DC plan sponsors should monitor forthcoming clarifications closely, though no immediate action is required pending the agency's formal position. The order's emphasis on fiduciary discretion in determining risk-adjusted return enhancement suggests the final guidance will grant significant latitude to plan sponsors in structuring alternatives exposure for participants.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.