AlphaMaven AlphaMaven

Private credit faces lower return expectations, manager differentiation after year of ‘confidence’ issues

Reported by Pensions & Investments
Nov 19, 2026· 3 min read
Save Post LinkedIn Email
Key Takeaways
  • • Canada Pension Plan Investment Board's David Colla said private credit direct lending returns have fallen to around 10%, not the 14-15% previously achieved, with stress lasting about four years since rates rose.
  • • Managers expect greater return dispersion among private credit managers, with Main Street Capital's Nick Meserve saying the shakeout will wash out newer or less experienced players.
  • • Hamilton Lane's Nayef Perry characterized the past year as a cycle of confidence rather than fundamental breakdown, describing the asset class as on "very stable footing" with benign defaults.
  • • Pensions & Investments has tracked 174 private credit hires totaling $33.2 billion through Nov. 16, indicating continued institutional allocation despite lower return expectations.
  • • Managers are pointing to defensible vertical software, industrial services, and aerospace and defense as areas of optimism.
Summary
The private credit industry is confronting lower return expectations and growing manager dispersion as it works through a period of investor "confidence" issues, according to industry executives speaking at the SuperReturn Private Credit North America conference in New York, as reported by Pensions & Investments and Lydia Tomkiw.

David Colla, senior managing director and global head of credit investments at the C$866.2 billion ($605 billion) Canada Pension Plan Investment Board, said the stress in private credit direct lending is real and has persisted for four years since interest rates rose. "You're not making 14 (percent), 15% returns. You're making 10% returns," he said, adding that the downturn has been protracted rather than sharp, unlike the Global Financial Crisis. CPP holds C$90 billion in credit investments and, in private credit, seeks "leading edge, innovative, proven-type of managers" and typically avoids managers that are just starting out.

Despite the diminished returns, institutional allocation continues. Pensions & Investments has tracked 174 private credit hires totaling $33.2 billion through Nov. 16. Nick Meserve, head of private credit at the $9 billion Main Street Capital Corporation, said he expects more differentiation among managers, which he believes will be healthy for the industry and will eliminate participants that entered recently or lack experience.

Nayef Perry, head of direct credit at the $1 trillion Hamilton Lane, described the year as a "cycle of confidence, not a cycle based on any breakdown in the fundamentals," and said the industry remains on "very stable footing" with a generally benign default environment. Luke Jackson, a partner focused on residential mortgage finance at Castlelake, said underlying asset performance across consumer, mortgage and small business lending has not been the problem; challenges have centered on retail capital entering the asset class, which Castlelake said it has avoided.

Consultants are also continuing to engage. Dan Lax, senior investment director at Cambridge Associates, said the firm is growing its private credit commitments across client types while being more selective about where incremental capital goes, with increased focus on niche strategies and diversification.

Managers are identifying areas of conviction despite AI-related software disruption concerns. Carolyn Hastings, a partner at Bain Capital, cited vertically built software serving specific industries such as healthcare and insurance as more defensible, and pointed to core middle-market lending to industrial services firms, including HVAC and leak detection companies whose products are used in data centers. Alex Dashiell, partner and head of origination at Willow Tree Credit Partners, said the firm is bullish on aerospace and defense tied to domestic infrastructure rebuilding, as well as the wealth management sector.

Go deeper than the headline

Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.

Start your free 7-day trial

Sources

1 outlet

AlphaMaven summarised this story from the reporting below. Each link opens the original article.

Pensions & Investments Private credit faces lower return expectations, manager differentiation after year of ‘confidence’ issues