Key Takeaways
- • A median cryptocurrency from a random sampling of the top 1,000 by market capitalization declined 46.6% from August 2017 to August 2022, compared to a 56.4% gain for total stock market index funds and 60.8% for S&P 500 index funds over the same period, according to research by Algernon Austin at the Center for Economic and Policy Research.
- • Cryptocurrency is being actively marketed to Black Americans as a solution to historical financial disenfranchisement and the racial wealth gap, with high-profile athletes like LeBron James lending credibility through partnerships with crypto platforms such as Crypto.com.
- • Financial experts characterize crypto investing as "extremely high risk" and closer to gambling than legitimate wealth-building, particularly problematic for financially vulnerable populations seeking generational wealth strategies.
- • Low-income Black families are advised to avoid speculative cryptocurrency investments without professional financial guidance and instead prioritize diversified, low-cost index funds as a more reliable path to wealth accumulation.
- • Data indicates Black consumers are more likely to own cryptocurrency than stocks or mutual funds, despite the superior historical performance and lower risk profile of traditional equity index products.
Summary
Cryptocurrency is being heavily promoted to Black Americans as a pathway to generational wealth and as a remedy for decades of systemic financial exclusion. However, financial research and expert analysis suggest this narrative obscures the high-risk, speculative nature of digital assets and may actually harm wealth-building objectives for vulnerable populations.
The marketing push includes partnerships with prominent figures: LeBron James' family foundation has partnered with Crypto.com to teach communities about blockchain technology and digital assets. In a statement accompanying the partnership, James emphasized that "blockchain technology is revolutionizing our economy, sports and entertainment, the art world, and how we engage with one another," positioning cryptocurrency as essential to ensuring communities "are not left behind." Similar pitches have been delivered at seminars and Zoom calls targeting Black investors and communities.
Yet the empirical evidence contradicts this optimistic framing. Research released earlier in 2023 by Algernon Austin, director for Race and Economic Justice at the Center for Economic and Policy Research, directly compared cryptocurrency performance to traditional index funds. Analyzing a random sample of 100 cryptocurrencies from the top 1,000 by market capitalization, Austin's team found that the median cryptocurrency lost 46.6% of its value between August 2017 and August 2022. Over the same period, a total stock market index fund gained 56.4%, while an S&P 500 index fund surged 60.8%. Austin characterized crypto investing as "extremely high risk" and stated it is "closer to gambling" than legitimate investment strategy.
Industry experts recommend that low-income Black families avoid speculative cryptocurrency without professional financial advisory support, instead prioritizing low-cost, diversified stock index funds as proven wealth-building vehicles. The concern is particularly acute given data indicating that Black consumers are statistically more likely to own cryptocurrency than stocks or mutual funds—a portfolio allocation pattern contradicted by historical risk-adjusted returns and financial theory.
The marketing push includes partnerships with prominent figures: LeBron James' family foundation has partnered with Crypto.com to teach communities about blockchain technology and digital assets. In a statement accompanying the partnership, James emphasized that "blockchain technology is revolutionizing our economy, sports and entertainment, the art world, and how we engage with one another," positioning cryptocurrency as essential to ensuring communities "are not left behind." Similar pitches have been delivered at seminars and Zoom calls targeting Black investors and communities.
Yet the empirical evidence contradicts this optimistic framing. Research released earlier in 2023 by Algernon Austin, director for Race and Economic Justice at the Center for Economic and Policy Research, directly compared cryptocurrency performance to traditional index funds. Analyzing a random sample of 100 cryptocurrencies from the top 1,000 by market capitalization, Austin's team found that the median cryptocurrency lost 46.6% of its value between August 2017 and August 2022. Over the same period, a total stock market index fund gained 56.4%, while an S&P 500 index fund surged 60.8%. Austin characterized crypto investing as "extremely high risk" and stated it is "closer to gambling" than legitimate investment strategy.
Industry experts recommend that low-income Black families avoid speculative cryptocurrency without professional financial advisory support, instead prioritizing low-cost, diversified stock index funds as proven wealth-building vehicles. The concern is particularly acute given data indicating that Black consumers are statistically more likely to own cryptocurrency than stocks or mutual funds—a portfolio allocation pattern contradicted by historical risk-adjusted returns and financial theory.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.