Key Takeaways
- • Consumer Reports evaluated five major crypto exchanges (Binance.US, Coinbase, Crypto.com, Gemini and Kraken) and found all five made it easy to start trading, but key details such as fees, how they are calculated, and customer protections were not always easy to find.
- • None of the five platforms clearly disclosed during sign-up that crypto held on an exchange lacks the federal bank-deposit protections that apply to money in a bank, meaning customers could lose some or all of their holdings if an exchange fails or is hacked.
- • Fraud warnings varied: Gemini required customers to acknowledge multiple fraud risks, Binance.US, Coinbase and Crypto.com used easily dismissed warnings, and Kraken showed no warning during transfers.
- • None of the exchanges limited the amount of user data collected, and Coinbase was the only platform offering an in-app option to request access to or deletion of personal data.
- • Consumer Reports recommends asking four questions before choosing a platform: what am I really paying, how does it protect against scams, what happens to my money if the company fails, and what it does with my data.
Summary
A central finding concerns federal protections. Consumer Reports found that none of the platforms clearly explained during sign-up that crypto held on an exchange does not carry the same federal protections as bank deposits. If an exchange fails or is hacked, customers could lose some or all of their investment. The group said exchanges should present clear information before customers send crypto, noting that crypto transfers may be difficult or impossible to reverse and that scammers increasingly target crypto users.
Fraud warnings also differed across platforms. Gemini required customers to acknowledge several fraud risks, while Binance.US, Coinbase and Crypto.com displayed warnings that were easier to dismiss, and Kraken showed no warning during the transfer process, according to Consumer Reports.
Privacy was another area of concern. The group found that none of the exchanges limited the volume of user data they collect, and Coinbase was the only platform offering an in-app mechanism to request access to or deletion of personal data. Binance.US, Coinbase, Crypto.com and Kraken responded by citing security, privacy, education, fraud-prevention or transparency measures they maintain; Gemini declined to comment on the record.
Before selecting an exchange or app, Consumer Reports recommends that users ask four questions: what they are really paying, how the platform helps protect them from scams, what happens to their money if the company goes under, and what the platform does with their data. For investors seeking crypto exposure without using an exchange, the group suggests a crypto ETF or index fund through a traditional brokerage, which may carry stronger federal oversight and consumer protections.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.