Key Takeaways
- • Only 32%-56% of cryptocurrency owners report their transactions to the IRS, according to recent academic research, indicating a significant compliance gap despite heightened regulatory scrutiny and new reporting requirements.
- • 61% of U.S. crypto investors remain unaware of 2025 IRS tax rules, including the new Form 1099-DA digital asset reporting requirement, according to a Coinbase and CoinTracker survey of 3,000 Americans conducted in fall 2025.
- • Widespread misunderstanding of taxable events persists: only 49% of surveyed crypto users correctly identified that selling cryptocurrency triggers a taxable event, while 41% incorrectly believed transferring to a bank account creates tax liability.
- • Knowledge gaps create enforcement vulnerability: while 74% of crypto users acknowledge crypto is taxable and 65% have previously reported crypto activity, the disconnect between awareness and accurate filing creates potential penalties up to $100,000 and criminal exposure.
- • Cost basis tracking emerges as a critical pain point: under 2025 rules, investors must calculate and reconcile adjusted cost basis themselves across platforms, as brokers are not required to provide cost basis accounting to the IRS, complicating compliance efforts.
Summary
A widening tax compliance gap has emerged among U.S. cryptocurrency investors ahead of the April 15, 2026 tax filing deadline, with academic research and industry surveys revealing that between 32% and 56% of crypto owners may be reporting their transactions to the IRS—indicating that a substantial majority are failing to file required disclosures. The finding underscores a critical vulnerability in the IRS's enforcement infrastructure even as the agency has substantially revamped cryptocurrency reporting requirements in recent years.
The compliance challenge reflects a paradox: while 74% of crypto users surveyed acknowledge that cryptocurrency activities are taxable and 65% claim to have previously reported crypto on their returns, roughly two-thirds of American crypto investors remain unaware of specific new IRS rules introduced for 2025 tax reporting. A joint survey by Coinbase and CoinTracker, conducted in fall 2025 among 3,000 U.S. crypto investors, found that 61% were unfamiliar with these updated requirements, despite their direct financial implications. "The story this data tells is one of confusion," Lawrence Zlatkin, Coinbase's vice president of tax, stated in the report. "Users are struggling to navigate the complexities of crypto taxation, which is why it's so important for us to help bridge that knowledge gap."
The centerpiece of the new regulatory framework is the IRS Form 1099-DA, which codifies broker reporting requirements for digital asset transactions beginning with 2025 tax filings. Starting in 2026, the IRS will receive copies of all 1099-DA forms issued, providing unprecedented visibility into gross proceeds from crypto sales and exchanges, along with transaction dates and wallet addresses. However, the survey revealed fundamental misunderstandings about what constitutes a taxable event: only 49% of respondents correctly identified that selling cryptocurrency triggers tax liability, while 41% incorrectly believed transferring assets to a bank account created tax obligations, and nearly 25% mistakenly considered transfers between personal wallets as taxable events.
A particularly vexing implementation challenge centers on cost basis reconciliation. Because brokers are not required to provide cost basis accounting to the IRS for 2025, individual investors bear sole responsibility for calculating and reconciling adjusted cost basis across multiple platforms—a process that Shehan Chandrasekera, head of tax strategy at CoinTracker, described as "uniquely hard to solve." This gap creates conditions where some taxpayers check the digital asset disclosure box on their returns without subsequently reporting gains and losses. The stakes are substantial: intentional tax fraud can result in penalties up to $100,000 and five years in prison, though such severe consequences would apply only to cases of serious, deliberate wrongdoing rather than filing errors. For institutional investors and family offices with significant crypto exposure, the compliance landscape presents both a risk management imperative and an operational challenge that extends beyond individual retail investors.
The compliance challenge reflects a paradox: while 74% of crypto users surveyed acknowledge that cryptocurrency activities are taxable and 65% claim to have previously reported crypto on their returns, roughly two-thirds of American crypto investors remain unaware of specific new IRS rules introduced for 2025 tax reporting. A joint survey by Coinbase and CoinTracker, conducted in fall 2025 among 3,000 U.S. crypto investors, found that 61% were unfamiliar with these updated requirements, despite their direct financial implications. "The story this data tells is one of confusion," Lawrence Zlatkin, Coinbase's vice president of tax, stated in the report. "Users are struggling to navigate the complexities of crypto taxation, which is why it's so important for us to help bridge that knowledge gap."
The centerpiece of the new regulatory framework is the IRS Form 1099-DA, which codifies broker reporting requirements for digital asset transactions beginning with 2025 tax filings. Starting in 2026, the IRS will receive copies of all 1099-DA forms issued, providing unprecedented visibility into gross proceeds from crypto sales and exchanges, along with transaction dates and wallet addresses. However, the survey revealed fundamental misunderstandings about what constitutes a taxable event: only 49% of respondents correctly identified that selling cryptocurrency triggers tax liability, while 41% incorrectly believed transferring assets to a bank account created tax obligations, and nearly 25% mistakenly considered transfers between personal wallets as taxable events.
A particularly vexing implementation challenge centers on cost basis reconciliation. Because brokers are not required to provide cost basis accounting to the IRS for 2025, individual investors bear sole responsibility for calculating and reconciling adjusted cost basis across multiple platforms—a process that Shehan Chandrasekera, head of tax strategy at CoinTracker, described as "uniquely hard to solve." This gap creates conditions where some taxpayers check the digital asset disclosure box on their returns without subsequently reporting gains and losses. The stakes are substantial: intentional tax fraud can result in penalties up to $100,000 and five years in prison, though such severe consequences would apply only to cases of serious, deliberate wrongdoing rather than filing errors. For institutional investors and family offices with significant crypto exposure, the compliance landscape presents both a risk management imperative and an operational challenge that extends beyond individual retail investors.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.