Key Takeaways
- • Hedge funds declined 3.1% in October 2018 and posted a 2% loss through the first 11 months of the year, marking a brutal performance period for the industry.
- • Tech-heavy hedge funds experienced a record monthly loss of 10.2% in July, driven by margin calls and forced selling as positions unwound sharply.
- • Quantitative hedge funds suffered their worst single day in over six months, losing approximately 1.3% as the industry rushed to unwind falling-market bets.
- • Hedge fund closures have outpaced launches, with the number of active funds declining to 8,946 and attrition rates reaching 3.2% to 4% during the first half of 2018.
- • Investors are increasingly frustrated with hedge funds' persistently weak performance relative to low-cost alternatives, intensifying pressure on the industry's traditionally high fee structures.
Summary
The hedge fund industry entered 2019 facing a period of severe underperformance and structural headwinds that have tested investor confidence and fund viability. Through the first 11 months of 2018, hedge funds posted aggregate losses of 2%, with October marking a particularly sharp decline of 3.1%. This extended period of weakness stands in sharp contrast to the stability investors expect from supposedly sophisticated, actively managed strategies.
Tech-focused hedge funds bore the brunt of market volatility in July 2018, experiencing a record monthly decline of 10.2%, according to JPMorgan estimates. This collapse was precipitated by a cascade of forced selling and margin calls as leveraged positions deteriorated rapidly. Quantitative hedge funds similarly suffered acute stress, posting their worst single-day loss in more than six months as managers rushed to unwind bets positioned for declining markets. These episodes underscore the vulnerability of crowded trades and the systemic risks posed when multiple large funds attempt to exit positions simultaneously.
The deteriorating performance backdrop has triggered a wave of fund liquidations that now outpaces new launches. According to HFR data, the total number of active hedge funds fell to 8,946, with attrition rates accelerating to 3.2% in the second quarter and 4% in the first quarter of 2018. This structural decline reflects both performance-driven redemptions and investor skepticism about the value proposition offered by traditional hedge fund models.
Investor dissatisfaction has intensified as the performance-to-fee calculus has deteriorated sharply. Hedge funds have historically charged 2% management fees and 20% performance fees—premiums justified only by outperformance relative to low-cost index alternatives. With aggregate underperformance now evident across multiple time periods and fund categories, institutional investors and family offices are increasingly questioning whether these fees remain justified. This fee-pressure dynamic, combined with extended underperformance and rising liquidations, presents a significant headwind for the broader hedge fund industry as it approaches 2019.
Tech-focused hedge funds bore the brunt of market volatility in July 2018, experiencing a record monthly decline of 10.2%, according to JPMorgan estimates. This collapse was precipitated by a cascade of forced selling and margin calls as leveraged positions deteriorated rapidly. Quantitative hedge funds similarly suffered acute stress, posting their worst single-day loss in more than six months as managers rushed to unwind bets positioned for declining markets. These episodes underscore the vulnerability of crowded trades and the systemic risks posed when multiple large funds attempt to exit positions simultaneously.
The deteriorating performance backdrop has triggered a wave of fund liquidations that now outpaces new launches. According to HFR data, the total number of active hedge funds fell to 8,946, with attrition rates accelerating to 3.2% in the second quarter and 4% in the first quarter of 2018. This structural decline reflects both performance-driven redemptions and investor skepticism about the value proposition offered by traditional hedge fund models.
Investor dissatisfaction has intensified as the performance-to-fee calculus has deteriorated sharply. Hedge funds have historically charged 2% management fees and 20% performance fees—premiums justified only by outperformance relative to low-cost index alternatives. With aggregate underperformance now evident across multiple time periods and fund categories, institutional investors and family offices are increasingly questioning whether these fees remain justified. This fee-pressure dynamic, combined with extended underperformance and rising liquidations, presents a significant headwind for the broader hedge fund industry as it approaches 2019.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.