Key Takeaways
- • Alternative hedge fund strategies underperformed major equity benchmarks in 2013, with the Barclay Hedge Fund Index up 11.79% and Fund of Funds index up 8.78%, compared to the S&P 500's 27% gain, positioning certain strategies for potential outperformance in a less predictable 2014 market.
- • Contrarian Capital's flagship Capital Fund I delivered 17% returns in 2013 by focusing on distressed debt opportunities including bank debt, real estate-backed debt, senior bonds, and trade claims—a strategy less dependent on equity market performance than traditional hedge funds.
- • Distressed debt strategies demonstrate resilience through claims acquisition mechanisms, exemplified by Contrarian's 2005 Refco bankruptcy case where the fund purchased creditor claims at discounts, capturing value through patient capital and immediate liquidity provision to claim sellers.
- • Alternative strategies are positioned to capture alpha in 2014 through manager skill in security selection within depressed asset classes rather than reliance on broad market appreciation.
Summary
Alternative hedge fund strategies entered 2014 with momentum after a challenging 2013 when traditional hedge fund benchmarks significantly lagged equity market performance. While the S&P 500 delivered 27% returns for the year, the Barclay Hedge Fund Index gained only 11.79% and the Fund of Funds index returned 8.78%, according to Hedge Fund Alpha. This performance divergence highlighted a critical bifurcation in the hedge fund landscape, with alternative strategies positioned to potentially outperform in market environments characterized by greater uncertainty and reduced correlation with broad equity indices.
Contrarian Capital emerged as a case study in alternative strategy outperformance, with its flagship Capital Fund I delivering just over 17% returns in 2013. The fund's primary investment thesis centers on distressed opportunities—specifically bank debt, real estate-backed debt, senior bonds, direct rescue financing, and trade claims. This strategy construction prioritizes manager skill in security selection and distressed situation evaluation over correlation with equity market direction, fundamentally differentiating it from long-only or traditional long/short equity approaches.
The mechanics of distressed debt investing were illustrated through Contrarian's involvement in the 2005 Refco bankruptcy. When the commodities broker-dealer collapsed following disclosure of $430 million in hidden debt by its CEO, Contrarian acquired bankruptcy claims from creditors unwilling to wait for resolution. Sellers of these claims typically accepted discounts to the claims' perceived market value in exchange for immediate capital access and elimination of payment uncertainty. This approach captures alpha through patient capital deployment and counterparty liquidity provision rather than broad market directional bets.
Contrarian Capital's 2013 performance and recognition—including nomination for Absolute Return's 2013 Awards and Institutional Investor's hedge fund awards—reflected the broader institutional appetite for strategies positioned to navigate a less predictable equity environment in 2014. As alternative strategies demonstrated their capacity to deliver meaningful returns independent of S&P 500 performance, institutional allocators increasingly viewed them as critical portfolio diversification tools for the evolving market regime ahead.
Contrarian Capital emerged as a case study in alternative strategy outperformance, with its flagship Capital Fund I delivering just over 17% returns in 2013. The fund's primary investment thesis centers on distressed opportunities—specifically bank debt, real estate-backed debt, senior bonds, direct rescue financing, and trade claims. This strategy construction prioritizes manager skill in security selection and distressed situation evaluation over correlation with equity market direction, fundamentally differentiating it from long-only or traditional long/short equity approaches.
The mechanics of distressed debt investing were illustrated through Contrarian's involvement in the 2005 Refco bankruptcy. When the commodities broker-dealer collapsed following disclosure of $430 million in hidden debt by its CEO, Contrarian acquired bankruptcy claims from creditors unwilling to wait for resolution. Sellers of these claims typically accepted discounts to the claims' perceived market value in exchange for immediate capital access and elimination of payment uncertainty. This approach captures alpha through patient capital deployment and counterparty liquidity provision rather than broad market directional bets.
Contrarian Capital's 2013 performance and recognition—including nomination for Absolute Return's 2013 Awards and Institutional Investor's hedge fund awards—reflected the broader institutional appetite for strategies positioned to navigate a less predictable equity environment in 2014. As alternative strategies demonstrated their capacity to deliver meaningful returns independent of S&P 500 performance, institutional allocators increasingly viewed them as critical portfolio diversification tools for the evolving market regime ahead.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.