Key Takeaways
- • Citi downgraded Pershing Square (NYSE: PS) to Sell from Neutral, maintaining a $45 per-share price target and citing a valuation of roughly 54 times forward earnings.
- • BofA downgraded PS to Underperform from Neutral and cut its price target from $54 to $38, implying about a 15% decline over 12 months.
- • PS shares peaked at $60 on Oct. 7 after opening at $24 on April 29 in a combined IPO with Pershing Square USA, then fell roughly 25% to about $45.
- • Citi cut its 2027 EPS estimate to $0.89 from $1.01, citing weak investment performance at Pershing Square Holdings and Pershing Square USA.
- • Fee-based revenue ties earnings to asset levels, so further fund-performance softness would compress the firm's income.
Summary
Shares of Pershing Square Inc. (NYSE: PS), the investment firm founded and led by Bill Ackman, have fallen sharply after two Wall Street downgrades within a single week. According to The Globe and Mail, the stock opened at $24 per share on April 29 in a combined initial public offering with the firm's Pershing Square USA fund, rose to a high of $60 on Oct. 7, and then declined about 25% to roughly $45.
Citi downgraded PS to Sell from Neutral and kept its $45 price target. The firm pointed to a valuation of about 54 times forward earnings expectations. Citi also reduced its 2027 earnings estimate to $0.89 per share from $1.01, reflecting tepid investment performance at the firm's two largest vehicles, Pershing Square Holdings and Pershing Square USA. Citi expects modest returns over the next year given market uncertainty. Even with the lower estimate, $0.89 would represent a significant increase over the roughly $0.51 per share in adjusted earnings analysts project for 2026.
BofA followed by downgrading PS to Underperform from Neutral and lowering its price target from $54 to $38 per share. That target implies a decline of about 15% over the next 12 months. BofA's concerns mirrored Citi's, centering on a high valuation relative to modest or negative expected returns.
The revenue model is central to the debate. Pershing Square earns a substantial share of revenue from investment management fees, so declines in managed assets reduce fee income. The firm plans to launch Pershing Square Ventures, a private equity fund offering access to pre-IPO companies, by the end of 2026, which could diversify its revenue base. The source characterizes the stock as overvalued following its post-IPO run, with investors likely taking profits near the peak.
Citi downgraded PS to Sell from Neutral and kept its $45 price target. The firm pointed to a valuation of about 54 times forward earnings expectations. Citi also reduced its 2027 earnings estimate to $0.89 per share from $1.01, reflecting tepid investment performance at the firm's two largest vehicles, Pershing Square Holdings and Pershing Square USA. Citi expects modest returns over the next year given market uncertainty. Even with the lower estimate, $0.89 would represent a significant increase over the roughly $0.51 per share in adjusted earnings analysts project for 2026.
BofA followed by downgrading PS to Underperform from Neutral and lowering its price target from $54 to $38 per share. That target implies a decline of about 15% over the next 12 months. BofA's concerns mirrored Citi's, centering on a high valuation relative to modest or negative expected returns.
The revenue model is central to the debate. Pershing Square earns a substantial share of revenue from investment management fees, so declines in managed assets reduce fee income. The firm plans to launch Pershing Square Ventures, a private equity fund offering access to pre-IPO companies, by the end of 2026, which could diversify its revenue base. The source characterizes the stock as overvalued following its post-IPO run, with investors likely taking profits near the peak.
Go deeper than the headline
Research every firm in this story, track the ones that matter and get the daily briefing — free for 7 days.